19.4 C
Byron Shire
October 28, 2021

Morrison and his Bully Boys caught with a dodgy credit card

Latest News

Concerns raised over the impact of opening up to tourists

The North Coast has seen a significant rise in vaccination however, spokesperson for the Cross Border Task Force and Tweed Shire Mayor Chris Cherry has told The Echo that there are significant concerns over the impacts as people start arriving from Sydney.

Other News

New plan to minimise flood hazard in Lismore

Lismore City Council has commenced the preparation of a new Flood Risk Management Plan that will identify the measures designed to minimise the community’s exposure to flood hazard.

Charges laid after police pursuit at Murwillumbah

Officers from Tweed/Byron Police District have been investigating several incidents of stolen motor vehicles from within the Kingscliff area over the past month.

NSW Legislative Council expresses concerns over push to burn native forests for power

The NSW Legislative Council unanimously passed a motion expressing its concerns over the growing push by industry to burn NSW native forests for electricity and hydrogen production.

#Bigbadbiomass rally at Condong sugar mill

Around 50 people gathered on Friday morning at the big fig tree near the Condong sugar mill to join the world-wide #Bigbadbiomass protest against the use of biomass to create energy and to emphasise that burning biomass is not ‘environmentally friendly’.

A dumb act of STP

Council is stating that breaches of licence conditions, in part, justifies spending $10m on transferring raw sewage from Ocean...

NSW Education responds to Teachers Federation over Murwillumbah Education Campus staff cuts

The NSW Education Department has responded to the NSW Teachers Federation's accusation that Education Minister Sarah Mitchell has only just revealed the extent of staff cuts at the mega school.


Phillip  Frazer

You may have seen headlines last week about the argy-bargy in the Senate over a ‘cashless credit card’ system for paying income support. These are payments made by the Treasury to cover some or all living costs for people disadvantaged by disability, youth, old age, being a carer or a student, or unemployed or underemployed, and more.

Why this is in the news now is that the Morrison government wants that money, which has traditionally been paid into people’s bank accounts, to be paid instead to a private company called Indue. If you are in the system you’re supposed to use the Indue debit card to buy things, except it can’t be used anywhere that offers alcohol, drugs, or gambling.

Card not effective

This system of ‘income management’ was introduced by the Howard government in 2007 to stop Indigenous Australians on support from wasting themselves and their money on sinful spending. Back then it was called the BasicsCard and basically, it didn’t work – and it doesn’t work now that it’s called the Indue card.

Federal governments – LibNat and Labor – have spent more than $20 million on establishing this Card-of-Shame system, and studying its effects. None of the reports we the taxpayers have funded found the cards are effective, which is why Labor, Greens, and cross-bench senators voted against expanding the thing in Parliament last week.

Racist and colonial

Jacqui Lambie spoke of ‘people who feel the pain of this policy failure’ and pointed out that, ‘Rather than treating the card as a single tool in the tool kit, government after government has treated it as the whole kit’.

Greens Senator, Lidia Thorpe, told the senate, ‘Management of income is racist and colonial nonsense all over again and it is demeaning to us… it’s putting black people back on rations.’

As usual the Morrison government tried to bully through their plan – which was to make the cards permanent in the trial areas and to expand them to 20,000 more Australians on income support. And as is becoming more usual, their bullying pissed off enough senators that the scheme was put on hold, except for continuing the trials for another two years, during which time the bullies need to table a plan.

Why are the Morrison Bully Boys pushing this?

All the impassioned speeches in the senate were about the pain and shame caused by the card, and the lack of evidence that it causes anything else. Many of them described the government’s mission here as ideological, which it is: the LibNat’s right wing libertarian dingbats reckon all poor people should just get off their arses, and Morrison himself reckons God’s light shines on those who make a lot of money.

That’s what passes for ideology in the Coalition, and it’s one of two reasons behind this Card-of-Shame sham.

Tax dollars for private business

The second is also an ideological conviction; that only business people, and private enterprise, are competent to run anything. In the 1970s, this antisocial premise launched a crusade, led by Thatcher and Reagan, to demolish public healthcare, education, housing and everything else not primarily designed for profit, like public spaces, environmental protections, art in any and every form, and thinking hard.

Howard and subsequent LibNat PMs followed the Reagan/Thatcher lead, being dutiful lapdogs of elitism, and set about demolishing our public service, unions, and the notion of common wealth. Then they handed over the tax savings to private businesses and told them to provide a mean and nasty version of a social support system (crowning glory being RoboDebt).

A monster child

Which brings us back to the Indue card. This thing is the monster child of the failed BasicsCard, a version of ‘income management’ first spearheaded by former Nationals Party boss Larry Anthony. It gives income support a privatised layer of money finagling that doesn’t need to be there, except to siphon off more of what used to be our tax money. It’s also a way for the LibNat Bully Boys of politics – Morrison, Dutton, Frydenberg, Angus Taylor etc – to make obsolete one of the aspects of government they hate most: accountability. How much does Indue rip off from us taxpayers, and how can we know about it?

That revolutionary mob called the St Vincent de Paul Society had a go at explaining it: ‘The Government spent nearly $18.9 million to trial the cashless debit card, which equates to over $10,000 per person in the trial. More than half ($9.8 million) of the total funding was paid to Indue, the private company contracted to cover all operational aspects of the cashless debit card.’

And on top of all that, the core crime here is the continuation of the degradation, impoverishment, and bullying of Australia’s First People.

♦ Phillip Frazer calls out bullies at Coorabell Ridge

Support The Echo

Keeping the community together and the community voice loud and clear is what The Echo is about. More than ever we need your help to keep this voice alive and thriving in the community.

Like all businesses we are struggling to keep food on the table of all our local and hard working journalists, artists, sales, delivery and drudges who keep the news coming out to you both in the newspaper and online. If you can spare a few dollars a week – or maybe more – we would appreciate all the support you are able to give to keep the voice of independent, local journalism alive.


  1. Phillip I am still mourning the loss of Mungo’s weekly lifeline to a saner world! Perhaps you would consider stepping into his shoes for awhile to give his many admirers enough time to adjust to a world less comprehensible without Mungo’s levening of sanity?

  2. Why, oh why do we not pay everyone a living wage? Then sort out the rest in the tax system. (Every $ earned would be taxed).
    Also, tax money into & out of the country, as the red-headed bimbo suggested many years ago (one of her few good ideas). That way the Googles & fast$ (farcebooks) would be taxed something at least!
    If the living wage was paid, we would only need a tiny Centrelink, & we could also get rid of the leeches that get paid to sometimes find the unemployed jobs.
    We surely do not need a private company to siphon taxpayer $s to run a cashless debit card (particularly when most credit unions would probably run it for nothing!)
    I really think we will look back on this mob of incompetents as being the worst government in memory! May they change next year!

  3. Given that our Federal politicians are serial offenders of their ‘spending entitlements’ the evidence is there that it the pollies that need to be put on the card.

  4. I would like to see a study around the effects of the increased rate of jobfinder allowance during covid. I personally know 2 people who used that support to set up their own businesses and create work that they wouldn’t otherwise have had. One of them is now an employer.

    I suspect that we would see that a whole portion of our community benefited from having the extra jobfinder money to pay their bills and buy decent groceries.

    Use the money the Indue card would cost us to give proper personalised help to those who have drug and alcohol problems (can’t believe I’m agreeing with Jacqui Lambie again) and give sufficient money to those who can’t work for whatever reason so that they have a reasonable quality of life. Why would we give it to some awful company that does nothing but create added problems and pressure for people doing it tough?

  5. The card is ‘a pain & a shame-game’. The country can do better than that
    so we wait again to discover ScoMo’s next tactic.

  6. This whole cdc indue card is a farce, its causing homelessness, suicides ,mental health issues, bad credit ratings….i hope you are proud of yourself you elitist pompous pitiful narcissistic evil money grabber
    It the end of the line for you scummo


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Should the Northern Rivers be opening up to mines?

The question of whether or not mining should be allowed in the Northern Rivers has once again been raised and the issue is being brought to the table in the NSW Parliament.

Paid parking review on the table for Byron Shire Council

Touted as their ‘first detailed policy position ahead of the Council elections’, the Byron Independents have announced their plans to expand pay parking in ‘other towns’ like Brunswick Heads and Mullumbimby.

Community sport warms up as restrictions recede

Amid the uncertainty of COVID-19 and the winding back of public health restrictions, summer sporting codes are doing what they can to get their season underway.

Freedoms and rights

Whilst I agree with most of Adrian Gattenhoff’s assertions in Letters (13 October: Perrotet and Opus Dei) I urge him not to be fooled...