14.1 C
Byron Shire
September 29, 2022

Editorial – Secret meeting held over poor governance

Latest News

It is a weekend of excitement, fun and laughter for everyone at the National Circus Festival

It truly is like stepping into another world as you enter The Famous Spiegeltent which is here for the National Circus Festival that is taking place this weekend in Mullumbimby before it once again heads off around the world.

Other News

Woman critically injured in fight; second woman charged with attempted murder – Tweed Heads

A woman remains in hospital in a critical condition and a second woman has been charged following an alleged stabbing at Tweed Heads yesterday.

Acid sulfate soil run off impacting health of fish and Tweed River

Acid sulfate soil (ASS)-related runoff from floodplain drains is affecting water quality and the health of fish in the Tweed River and Tweed Shire Council (TSC) are seeking to assist landholders with improving water quality projects. 

Byron Music Society’s Big Sing

Byron Music Society presents ‘A German Requiem by Johannes Brahms’ (Ein Deutsches Requiem), recognised as one of the greatest...

Plastic recycling to be turbocharged in NSW

The NSW Government says more plastic will be recycled and turned into new products across the state, thanks to $9 million in funding to support businesses transform their operations and access the latest plastic recycling technology.

AZTECA margarita mix

WANTED: Fun-loving person to spend two years eating tacos and sampling margaritas in Mexico with same. I’d answer that kind...

CSIRO tracking NASA’s asteroid collision test today

The world’s first full-scale planetary defence test is happening today. NASA’s Double Asteroid Redirection Test (DART) mission is designed to strike an asteroid and adjust its course.

Councillors, like all politicians, are in the unenviable position of trying to represent the interests of two parties that are often in conflict with each other. 

In the case of councillors, it is the community versus Council staff, and generally that conflict occurs within planning and compliance areas.

The Echo has been unapologetically hard on councillors with regard to their failings to represent the community in this regard. 

While Council staff may try their best to reflect Council policy or legislation, their advice may be wrong.

When you acquiesce to Council staff advice without question, the community are right to ask who you represent. 

But let’s take a moment to recognise when councillors actually do something that is reflective of what the community wants. How rare is that?

Byron Shire Mayor councillor Michael Lyon. Photo supplied

This week, the mayor of Byron Shire Council has broken the mould of doing whatever staff tell him. 

He is courageously seeking better outcomes in the future around a policy that led to a woman being fined $3,000 for refusing to change the colour of her Mullum house back to heritage colours. 

The latest chapter in the long running issue is here.

An attempt to drop the fine was previously made in March 2022 by Cr Duncan Dey, and was closely defeated. Crs Coorey, Westheimer, Hunter, Pugh, and Swivel voted against the motion, while Cr Dey, Ndiaye, Lyon and Balson were in favour.  

Then homeowner, Nicole Haberecht, has since sold her home and moved to Nimbin, disgusted at her treatment by staff and councillors. 

This time, the mayor seems to think he has the numbers to make right the wrong. 

Nicole Haberecht’s lilac house colour is incompatible with NSW and Council heritage conservation policy. Photo supplied.


Yet staff have flagged they want to conduct any debate on this in secrecy, claiming that it contains ‘personal matters concerning particular individuals’ and ‘discussion in relation to personal hardship of a resident or ratepayer’. 

A possible reason for confidential meetings is Council’s addiction to secrecy and potential embarrassment around how it’s been handled.

All the information about this case is already publicly available, because The Echo and other media reported on it at the time. 

The previous ‘report’ that assisted councillors in making their decision was authored by Council’s legal counsel, Ralph James. 

It was selective at best, because it failed to present Haberecht’s side of the story, something which The Echo sought to do.

Ms Haberecht told The Echo at the time, ‘I told them I was away for three months, looking after my elderly mother, and have also been recovering from mental and physical health issues’.

The Echo asked Mr James at the time, ‘Were you aware of this, and if so, was there a reason this information was omitted from your report?’ 

There was no reply.

Planning/compliance director, Shannon Burt told Council in March that every effort was made to negotiate with Ms Haberecht and assist her in returning the home to a heritage approved colour. 

Ms Haberecht disagrees. 

Another aspect to Mr James’s legal advice for this week’s meeting relates to the ‘whether the elected council can/should not [sic] intervene in the operational aspects of the exercise of Council’s regulatory functions’.

Shouldn’t councillors question poor policy and intervene in operational matters when it is causing reputational damage to Council? 

Come on councillors. 

There’s a term for those who do what the bureaucracy wants: useful idiots.

Get a spine and represent the community for a change. 

And make it transparent.

Hans Lovejoy, editor

News tips are welcome: [email protected]

Support The Echo

Keeping the community together and the community voice loud and clear is what The Echo is about. More than ever we need your help to keep this voice alive and thriving in the community.

Like all businesses we are struggling to keep food on the table of all our local and hard working journalists, artists, sales, delivery and drudges who keep the news coming out to you both in the newspaper and online. If you can spare a few dollars a week – or maybe more – we would appreciate all the support you are able to give to keep the voice of independent, local journalism alive.


  1. That’s only mildly ugly, but her house and her paint, ain’t no one elses business. What’s the charge? Aggravated Assault of other people’s eyeballs? If you don’t like it, don’t look at it, she is the Queen of her Castle.

    • If the house is NOT in a Heritage Area, I broadly agree.
      But if it is in one, then an awful eyesore like this detracts from the whole.
      Perhaps Nimbin may like it though…

  2. The rules clearly state that any external works to a house in a heritage area requires to be in line with the heritage considerations.

    She painted her house the WRONG colour, if she wants a purple house, don’t buy a house in a heritage area.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Iron Gates developer launches appeal against DA refusal at Evans Head

It is a saga that has been going on for over 30 years and that some hoped might finally have come to an end. But that is not to be the case with an appeal against the refusal of the Iron Gates development application (DA) at Evans Head now having been submitted.

Consideration of state significant farmland for SUGA development leaves bitter taste

One of Ballina Shire Council’s independents is continuing to argue against suggested expansions of development between the plateau villages of Alstonville and Wollongbar.

Editorial – Break out the bubbly for Budget Estimates

Budget Estimates is truly one of the most revealing and best educational services that the NSW government offers. MPs from the opposition grill ministers and agency bosses without mercy, for hours. 

Businesses launch campaign against holiday let policy

Businesses who say they would be adversely impacted by Council’s proposal to cap holiday letting to 90 days have gone on the offensive by launching a PR campaign.