13 C
Byron Shire
July 14, 2024

The Northern Rivers Reconstruction Corporation debate in Lismore

Latest News

While Hamas exists, Palestine will never be free

In response to David Heilpern’s article regarding antisemitism and Israel, (Echo, July 3) it is probably generally agreed that...

Other News

Fingal residents celebrate Cubby Bakehouse backdown over illegal development

The illegal development of the Fingal General Store into a commercial bakery was ended on Tuesday when Cubby’s development application (DA) was modified to remove the commercial bakery.


Edward Kent’s letter, Wallum (June 26), tried to diminish the importance of the Save Wallum campaign to mere ‘piffle’,...

Celebrate Argentine Cuisine every friday at Crystalbrook Byron’s Parilla BBQ

During the month of July, Crystalbrook Byron will be running ‘Parilla BBQ Fridays’, a culinary experience inspired by Argentine...

Should Mullum’s water supply remain locally-sourced?

The Echo asked mayoral candidates Cr Sarah Ndiaye and Mayor Michael Lyon what their position is with Mullum’s future water supply, and ‘Why the community should trust the integrity of this process, given the optics around consultant conflict of interest, and staff not answering questions from committee members with engineering expertise?’

A fairytale end to Skullcandy Oz Grom Open

Organisers of the Skullcandy Oz Grom Open say yesterday's final event was a fairytale finish to the competition with...

Karkalla at Home: 110 recipes using native foods

Karkalla at Home is a vibrant cookbook that brings Australia’s wonderful bounty of unique native foods into the home...

The New South Wales Government website says that the Northern Rivers Reconstruction Corporation (NRRC) leads and coordinates reconstruction activities for essential assets, infrastructure and housing in the Northern Rivers.

On Tuesday Councillor Adam Guise proposed that Lismore Council negotiate with the NRRC to acquire suitably identified land for housing, and prioritise such lands to be developed as social and affordable housing, supporting relocation for flood-impacted residents.

Cr Guise noted that Lismore Council is intending to rezone farmland to residential as part of its revised Growth & Realignment Management Strategy (GMS), under the premise of providing flood-free housing. This includes the plan to quadruple the size of The Channon village, double the size of Bexhill, double the size of Clunes, triple the size of Caniaba, double the size of Wyrallah, spread eastwards beyond the ‘pink line’ of Lismore’s outskirts, and expand Modanville and Tullera.

‘Rezoning land from RU1 agricultural to R1 housing exponentially increases the value of the land… for the landowner and developer,’ he said.

‘The Northern Rivers Reconstruction Corporation (which will become the permanent NSW Reconstruction Authority- NSWRA) already has the power to acquire land on just terms. It could, acting in the public interest, acquire such lands identified in the GMS as future housing before the land is rezoned to residential, saving taxpayers and ratepayers millions of dollars.

‘Acquiring the land after rezoning, or leaving it to the private market to develop, would significantly enrich particular landholders to the detriment of the public interest and providing social and affordable housing to those who need it.’

Cr Guise said Council should be working with the NRRC/NSWRA, flood-impacted residents and communities to acquire suitable land before rezoning it, and develop it as housing for flood impacted residents.

‘It is conceivable that this could be done in a faster and more affordable manner than leaving it to the market and for-profit developers.’

More control to the NRRC/NSWRA?

‘Developing such land in this way would give more control to the NRRC/NSWRA to determine the design of the development in accordance with principles of ecologically sustainable development and healthy urban design,’ said Cr Guise.

‘In particular, building healthy, happy and sustainable housing that is affordable to people, particularly the most vulnerable in our community.

‘Critically, Lismore Council should not be rushing to rezone future residential lands without first implementing an Affordable Housing Contributions Scheme which we’ve been told will take years to implement.’

Can for-profit developers solve the housing crisis?

Cr Guise said Lismore Council should not be leaving it to the for-profit developer-driven market to solve the Northern Rivers housing crisis.

‘This crisis presents an opportunity for the government to demonstrate leadership in solving the housing crisis, by moving people who are living on the floodplain from harm’s way and caring for our most vulnerable in their time of need.

‘Critically, the government must take an equity lens to flood recovery, ensuring that disaster capitalism does not dictate the winners and losers, and instead use this opportunity to address housing inequality once and for all through well-designed affordable and social housing as well as buybacks and house relocations.’

A spokesperson for Reclaiming our Recovery, Trevor Acfield, made comments in support of the motion during Public Access.

‘We have a really great opportunity here to build some brilliant new suburbs that are affordable and diverse,’ he said. ‘We need to ensure that the best value for residents and indeed the Council, is achieved. Councillor Guise’s motion is at the heart of this.’

‘We don’t want developers to be the major financial winners’

Mr Acfield continued: ‘We don’t want developers to be the major financial winners here. We want this Council and this community to be the winners.’

He said many people in the flood-affected areas want to move their houses to safer places. ‘I’m one of them. Many of us love our homes but we know we are not safe anymore.

‘But it’s not just the flood affected there are many who are suffering housing stress. We need federal, state and Lismore Council to assist us and develop the suburbs we need and we can be creative with good planning infrastructure and services.’

Other speakers on the issue included Adam Bruce-Allen, also from Reclaiming our Recovery, who as a registered nurse working in the mental health field, echoes many of Mr Acfield’s comments.

He asked, ‘Are we really so churlish that we don’t want to risk people whose land had a lower value getting a block worth more than the one they lost? Would that damage the social hierarchy too much? Let’s manage our own future and acquire land before rezoning and not afterwards.’

Clunes and the Growth and Realignment Strategy

Scott Hargrave spoke for the Friends of Clunes, calling on Council to remove the proposed development for Clunes from the Small City Council’s Draft Growth and Realignment Strategy currently on exhibition.

The Mayor mentioned that comments about the Clunes subdivision were not relevant to the motion. Mr Hargrave said he believed it was quite relevant.

‘The proposed development seems to have very little to do with alleviating the stress for people that are looking for housing, to be relocated to be moved out of harm’s way. It seems to have an awful lot to do with two entities who will do quite well out of this if the land was rezoned.’

People ‘kicked out’ of their land

Cr Big Rob wanted to remind Public Access petitioners that much of the land would see people ‘kicked out’ of their land as it would be compulsorily acquired and the value of that land would be substantially increased.

During the debate, Cr Guise said that the community members who spoke articulated the essence of what he was trying to get across. ‘If we didn’t have a housing crisis before the flood, it has been exacerbated tenfold now, and as the mayor has said in the past, it’s time to do things differently.

‘We can’t keep on leaving it to the market to develop land to drip feed it to us at exorbitant prices, and think that’s going to solve the social and affordable housing situation.’

Cr Guise said he didn’t that opening up more land for people with a lot more money from out of town to buy and develop would free up houses for the flood-impacted population to move into.

‘That’s not going to happen. It won’t happen overnight. And it certainly will not happen without government input and intervention.’

This is an opportunity

Cr Guise continued: ‘We’ve got this opportunity. It’s not about kicking people out of their homes. This is about identifying those parts of farmland or villages, or the bits we’ve got on our map and asking the corporation to acquire them on just terms as is already allowed under legislation.

‘We need to prioritise this housing for those already in housing stress, those who have been for decades and those that have been exposed to this, under these catastrophic flood and future extreme weather events that will be inflicted upon us.

‘Let’s set the example and the trend for doing it differently and use the corporation to make affordable and social housing for those who need it. Please think outside the box Councillors and don’t think that we can keep doing things the way we have, and get different results.’

The mayor then put the motion to a vote – Councillors Bird, Ekins, Cook and Guise voted for – those opposed were Big Rob and Team Krieg.

After the vote, Cr Guise said he was shocked and disappointed that the Krieg majority did not want Council to work with the NRRC to find affordable housing solutions for Lismore’s flood-impacted residents.

‘Our community has been very vocal about having a say in their future,’ he said. ‘By not supporting this motion, they’ve shut the community out of having a say.’

Support The Echo

Keeping the community together and the community voice loud and clear is what The Echo is about. More than ever we need your help to keep this voice alive and thriving in the community.

Like all businesses we are struggling to keep food on the table of all our local and hard working journalists, artists, sales, delivery and drudges who keep the news coming out to you both in the newspaper and online. If you can spare a few dollars a week – or maybe more – we would appreciate all the support you are able to give to keep the voice of independent, local journalism alive.


  1. Well, it does not come as surprise that Team Kreig has the developers’ interests at heart.
    They are a disgrace. They have given up the chance to do something great for the community and passed it up. Shame on them.

  2. Another Community call out! Krieg & Co roll on. Naturally the Devil, once again, had nothing to do with it. How high’s the
    soapbox, Mamma? Six foot high and rising.

  3. The ideological divide becoming more and more apparent. This motion was just way too much like socialism for these dedicated neo-liberal capitalists, I guess. But the lack of even a pretence of compassion and care from the Krieg team, at this time of such unprecedented disaster … or even something vaguely like proactive advocacy on the behalf of the community they represent, makes me wonder what they think they’re actually doing for any of us that is of benefit or use?

  4. One way to solve the problem is to approach landowners who own land in rural areas considered for residential housing to sell their land or parts of it, direct to the NRRC voluntarily. NRRC can then work with council to rezone and develop as a not for profit org. There will be some land owners who will consider a direct off market sale for lots of reasons especially quick settlement. In many similar cases the state and local councils offer purchase and re-zoning packages that avoid a lot of legals and time. Surprising as it might be, not all landowners want the highest price for their land, particularly when they can help out the community and get some recognition. They are pretty rare but maybe there should be a call for interested landowners to approach the corp and/or make it public. Im sure they are out there .. they are the key to moving forward.

    • The NRCC say they have already had so many expressions of interest in selling them land that they don’t need to contact landowners directly to let them know that land is being acquired. I hope this isn’t going to be a situation where only those in the know because of someone they know gets a look in to sell their land. The idea that land is going to be acquired against the will of the current owners is ridiculous. Just like too many of our esteemed councillors.

  5. Q : If you were a landowner with a suitable subdivision area for a new “South Lismore Estate” – would you sell it for low 1(a) agricultural value?
    Then – immediately afterwards have it re-zoned as Residential 2(a) with a humungous increase in $/hectare ‘in globo’ value.
    (Come on, only ‘dyed-in-the-wool-progressive’ socialists would fall for that crazyness and lack of reality ! )
    A : Of course, you could then be praised as a generous philanthropist – [unless you were heavily reimbursed afterwards with yet more of our tax-payer funds.]
    Un-fortunately not everyone can be Bill Gates.
    So please wise-up to the real world recalcitrant LCC Councilors.

    • I’m pretty sure there’ll be a landholder with suitable land that normally wouldn’t be easy to get through the red tape of subdividision who’d be happy to offload some at a good price.

  6. north lismore should already be developed providing hundreds of houses to the market, however this has been be protested against for years by the dark greens, and now they say they want land to develop housing? what a joke, its been there ready to go for over a decade

    • Perhaps Mick, the Guv’mint will buy each and every one a nice big block in the North Lismor Plateau development as a straight swap, paid for by taxpayer’s money.
      Now where’s that form to sign…..


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

A self-hating Jew

A self-hating Jew means ‘antisemite’. David Heilpern’s 3 July article was underpinned with lies, and hateful sentiments toward one group of Australians: the Jewish...

Losing town water access

I grew up and live in Mullumbimby, and I know locals have a strong opinion about the Byron Shire Council. I had always given...

Lavertys Gap history

The Lavertys Gap hydro power station was installed in 1919. In 1939, during the Great Depression, people had no money, and Council decided to...

Electricity lines clipped and lines come down in Lismore

Police have confirmed that a truck clipped powerlines today on Dawson Street, Lismore.