23.8 C
Byron Shire
February 5, 2023

Dingo Lane solar project – like other Council projects it doesn’t add up

Latest News

Swivel by name, drivel by nature

The lack of authenticity of Byron Councillor, Mark Swivel, does not come as a surprise from this side of...

Other News

Letters – 1 February 2023

The Echo loves your letters and is proud to provide a community forum on the issues that matter most to our readers and the people of the NSW north coast. So don’t be a passive reader, send us your epistles.

Swivel by name, drivel by nature

The lack of authenticity of Byron Councillor, Mark Swivel, does not come as a surprise from this side of...

Environment law fails to protect threatened species

A University of Queensland finding says that the federal environmental laws are failing to mitigate against Australia’s extinction crisis.

We’ve had the rain bomb, is a fire bomb next?

We had the Black Summer fires and then the floods and NSW Farmers says time is running out to prevent more mass bushfires at the end of this year.

Better outcomes start with teachers who believe in inclusive education

For all students – particularly those with additional needs – a teacher who doesn't believe in inclusive education can be harmful.

Edjamakashun pledges from NSW election candidates

NSW election candidates make their case for improving poor education standards  With Labor think tank, The McKell Institute, outlining a...

Artist’s impression of a future Myocum. Image supplied

The Dingo Lane Solar Farm development application (DA) has been passed by the Northern Regional Planning Panel (NRPP).

All the safeguards that were set up over time for the community’s wellbeing have just been trashed by the use of the Infrastructure SEPP. This planning trump card overrides everything. The State Government Large Scale Solar Guidelines, DCP (development control plans), LEP (Local Environment Plan), State Significant Farmland (SSF) mapping, wildlife corridors – these are all meaningless when it comes to infrastructure.

Not financially viable

Even more astounding is that the financial viability of a project is irrelevant when it comes before the NRPP.

The Preliminary Financial Report commissioned by Byron Shire Council in April 2019 estimated that the project’s investment would have a shortfall of around four million dollars over a 25-year period. This advice was ignored and the Council committed $600,000 to it!

This original analysis of curse did not forsee COVID, escalating interest rates, the war in Ukraine and the subsequent 25 to 40 per cent increases in construction costs.

At the April 2021 Council meeting, Councillor Paul Spooner raised concerns regarding the current financial estimates for the project and said that, ‘No commercial enterprise would take on the project, and the Council would have a 100 per cent debt-to-revenue ratio if they went ahead – and no other projects would be able to be done’.

In other words, the Council would be insolvent!

The Mayor (at that time), Simon Richardson, replied that ‘the financials stacked up’ to him.

The motion to continue with the DA was passed and the mayor resigned that night and took up a new job shortly after on the NRPP!

$3M in project development wasted?

The Council has now spent $1M of ratepayers’ funds to get this project to the DA stage.

More shocking is that Council has poured nearly $3M into the Vallances Road project, Sunrise bioenergy facility and the Dingo Lane Solar Project. None of the projects have stacked up as being viable.

The state government has set up Renewable Energy Zones in NSW. These zones are where the infrastructure for NSW Renewable Energy is being constructed and will be distributed from.

Twenty-five local Sydney councils have now partnered with Zen Energy, who is going to supply 100 per cent renewable energy to them from the Renewable Energy Zones. These councils are on a path to be Net Zero realistically sooner than Byron Shire’s estimated 2025.

Byron Shire Council’s model of ‘going it alone’ is financially fraught with only 17,000 ratepayers to pick up the bill. It is not in the community’s best interest to proceed with this Dingo Lane Solar Project.

Amalgamation?

Byron Shire Council used the future revenue from the West Byron development as the reason that they were ‘fit for governance’ and would not have to amalgamate with Ballina or Tweed Councils.

If this project were to proceed, and fail, the prospect of amalgamation will be inevitable. The prudent investment for Council, and for its ratepayers, would be to fund solar installations and batteries on Council’s individual assets. Byron Shire should also be looking at contracting their energy needs from the NSW Renewable Energy Zones and partnering with companies like Zen Energy.

Infrastructure questions

I sought independent advice from a large-scale solar consultant. He looked into the project and said that it was too far from the sub-station; the transmission lines are only 11kv and they are not close to the site. Upgrading the lines to cope with transmission would cost $1M plus. The energy generated would need to be sold to a supplier and a contract set up to buyback at a higher rate. Council would be at the mercy of the retailers.

He also said that the glare study (the glare and reflection study presented in the DA is for fixed panels only) didn’t take into account that if the panels rotate, they will adjust their angles to be oblique at sunrise and sunset. This creates reflection and glare for the surrounding properties. The vegetation screening would not adequately shield the surrounding hills from the project. He concluded, like Councillor Spooner, that realistically it was not a commercially viable project.

Large scale solar installations

In 2017 Council had another potential solar site and spent a lot of money investigating the Vallances Road Sewage Works site, they shelved the project because the substation was too far away. The Mullumbimby Substation was closer to that site than the Ewingsdale substation is to the Dingo Lane Solar site.

Byron Shire now has a far greater risk of being sold out to the developers. By default, Mayor Lyon is now blindly considering selling the Solar Project off to a private developer. If he does, he will let the genie out of the bottle and Byron Council and the community will have lost control forever.

The properties in Myocum valley have already been approached to have large-scale solar installations on their land and the carrot offered will be too big to be refused.

A five megawatt solar farm isn’t commercially viable, but a 150-megawatt installation would be.

The precedent is what Mayor Lyon would be selling and the NRPP would use the infrastructure SEPP to hand over our beautiful valleys to the developers forever.

♦ Tom McHugh is a Coorabell resident.


Support The Echo

Keeping the community together and the community voice loud and clear is what The Echo is about. More than ever we need your help to keep this voice alive and thriving in the community.

Like all businesses we are struggling to keep food on the table of all our local and hard working journalists, artists, sales, delivery and drudges who keep the news coming out to you both in the newspaper and online. If you can spare a few dollars a week – or maybe more – we would appreciate all the support you are able to give to keep the voice of independent, local journalism alive.

6 COMMENTS

  1. This is another signature project of Simon Richardson – is it any wonder the NRPP approved the project – unlike the huge phallus monument he raised on our doorstep this one will not be so easy to dismantle. And isn’t it nice to know that West Byron, the project Simon was “so opposed” to was uses to get the Council over the revenue line for “fit for governance” assessment on Simon’s watch as the “so opposed” Council installed the connector road for the roundabout intersection. Pull the other one.

  2. typical Nimby post, let me guess you live on coolamon scenic drive and think this is going to to negatively impact your property value? (which it won’t)

    how is a five megawatt solar farm not financially viable when a 2.5kw system on a house roof is ?

    love the blame ‘the developers’ catchphrase to try and get the nimby crew on your side.

    It is in the community interest to have local sustainable power generation over a few nimby’s worried about their view and selfish interests.

  3. Good on ya Mick, using a bit of good old fashioned, cultural division to press your argument, totally devoid of any facts or assessment.
    The problem mate, Is reckless unsupported spending of ratepayers funds.
    You should be on council bro!

  4. Tom what about if a pumped hydro system was located at Wilson Creek to store the generated electricity for reuse at night ? Raise the dam wall at Lavertys Gap and build a huge storage pond lower down near Mullum Golf Course (a recreational dam) . You could then buy fully sustainable electricity from a renewable energy generator.
    It may be so successful that even more solar farms could be built in the flood prone Tyagarah and Myocum paddocks .
    A huge win Green Byron .

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Land values rise

Your cover story on 25 January claims that land valuation rises could herald increases in Council rates. This is potentially misleading. A council’s total...

Go Thistles!

Lismore Thistles Soccer Club has launched the Thistles Acceleration Program, in the process becoming the city’s only player development academy. 

Pothole protest gets immediate results

Psst: want to get Council staff to do something about the appalling state of roads in your neighbourhood? Organise a protest outside Mullum’s Council Chambers! By...

What’s Love Got to Do with It?

Art imitates life in What’s Love Got to Do with It? a 2022 British romantic comedy-drama film directed by Shekhar Kapur, from a screenplay by Jemima Khan.  The precis reads: ‘Set between London and Lahore, a filmmaker documents her childhood friend and neighbour’s arranged marriage to a bride from Pakistan.’