23.2 C
Byron Shire
February 8, 2023

Byron Train – a view on viability

Latest News

Iron Gates development in Evans Head land owners go into administration – again

The Iron Gates development, that is on flood- and fire-prone land near Evans Head, has been fought by the community for over 30 years. The current company that owns the site, Goldcoral Pty Ltd whose director is Graeme Ingles, has now been placed into administration.

Other News

New SES Zone Commander for the north

The NSW State Emergency Service (NSW SES) has appointed a new Zone Commander for the northern part of the state.

We’ve had the rain bomb, is a fire bomb next?

We had the Black Summer fires and then the floods and NSW Farmers says time is running out to prevent more mass bushfires at the end of this year.

Corporate governance breaches

I totally agree with Warren’s comments on our system of free-market capitalism in Australia, (28 January). This is despite...

Protecting biodiversity will take more than just the ‘30×30’ target

A 2019 UN report Nature’s Dangerous Decline ‘Unprecedented’; Species Extinction Rates ‘Accelerating’ found that ‘nature is declining globally at rates unprecedented in human history’.

Teenage boys extorted over sexually explicit images

In the lead-up to tomorrow's Safer Internet Day the Kids Helpline is highlighting the concerning trend of overseas criminal syndicates preying on Australian children, particularly teenage boys, by extorting money from them after deceiving them to send sexually explicit images over instant messaging platforms.

It’s not the fossils, it’s the fools 

Humans have been muddling along in cities for around twelve thousand years, says Wikipedia, although if you count using an alphabet of some kind as the criterion of civilisation, the time span drops to a mere fifty centuries.

Byron’s solar train as it was delivered. Photo supplied

Raphael Lee Cass

Opinion

My jaw dropped in amazement when Byron Bay Train asked for volunteer train drivers and attendants. The requirements for these jobs were incredibly stringent. Train driver applicants needed availability for flexible work arrangements, to train others, to know all OH&S matters, do office work, maintenance work and many others. Volunteer Passenger Attendants needed just as much. An exceptional ask for volunteers.

The owner of Byron Bay Railroad Company Ltd is ultimately Brian Flannery, who declared the train open on December 16, 2017.

BRW Rich List

Flannery, according to the Financial Review, is a Brisbane-based engineer, has investments in uranium mining in Energy Resources of Australia, is a member of the BRW Rich List – after making $530 million from the sale of Felix Resources to Chinese firm Yanzhou Coal in 2009 – has shares in listed retirement village company Aveo, owns private property group KTQ Developments with wife Peggy and has projects including Brisbane apartments, $100–120million Elements of Byron Bay and childcare investments.

The train is a not-for-profit company. It means the train is financially isolated from Elements, doesn’t pay income tax, and any profit made must go back into the train business. It could be employing locals and enriching Byron. In my opinion asking for volunteers means only one thing that the business is not financially viable.

The train is a delightful ride through beautiful Byron. Like other trains, Puffing Billy and Zig Zag in Lithgow, it is there for tourism. It isn’t serious public transport.

Serious transport would have seen it travel from at least Byron Hospital to Byron Bay with a station at Cavanbah Centre .

Blanch’s bus service from Sunrise to Byron has low patronage. One morning the bus had one passenger but would no doubt pick up more on its way. The train had five passengers, with no stops before Byron town.

The Byron Train’s claim that the train would reduce the traffic on Ewingsdale road, made without any surveys whatsoever, can safely be disputed. At a generous estimate, there is an average of three cars parked near the station during train operations. Even if there were 20 cars parked there per hourly train trip [160 cars], this would have little effect on Ewingsdale Road’s 20,000 cars per day [RMS 2004].

In its second week of January 2018, Byron Train announced it had taken 10,000 passengers in 19 days. Assuming they didn’t include those riding free on the December 16, 2017 launch day, this works out to 32 passengers every trip. Go and watch the train’s. Thirty-two passengers is a rare occurrence.

I have travelled on the train many times. I observe passenger movements at the stations. I have never seen the train full (100 passengers). I have heard staff voice concerns about low patronage. If I reasonably estimate 20 passengers per trip for the seven-day service, 2,640 per week, at $3 per passenger, I get $411,840 income for the year. A train driver, with enormous passenger responsibility, earns around $95,000 per year. Byron Train has at least two professional drivers – that’s half the income used.

Maybe it’ll increase with the writers festival and other events. Or change the tickets to tourist prices, say $10 per trip, and then it’s $1.4M.

With its call for volunteers, low patronage, non-reduction of traffic on Ewingsdale Road, its claims to be a solar train, will the train be running in 2019? Or will it seek a government handout to keep its ‘public transport’ operating?

♦ Raphael Lee Cass is president of Sunrise Progress Association, who objected to the train.


Support The Echo

Keeping the community together and the community voice loud and clear is what The Echo is about. More than ever we need your help to keep this voice alive and thriving in the community.

Like all businesses we are struggling to keep food on the table of all our local and hard working journalists, artists, sales, delivery and drudges who keep the news coming out to you both in the newspaper and online. If you can spare a few dollars a week – or maybe more – we would appreciate all the support you are able to give to keep the voice of independent, local journalism alive.

4 COMMENTS

  1. The train is here to stay Lee. It’s not going away. Get over it. Move on.

    The recent call for volunteers was merely an attempt to fill existing empty positions for volunteers, and the paid positions have already been filled.

    It is beyond time you and your small group moved on. The train is here to stay. The sooner you accept this fact the better.

    • An informative and thought-provoking article, Lee. The train may indeed be here to stay, Wayne, but that doesn’t negate any of the points that are made here.

      Despite the fervour the venture has created in many that this is just the start of a rail/solar revolution, it is a novelty tourist train and assists travel between the industrial estate and the Shirley Street level crossing but is not serious public transport – unless I’m mistaken and this is the main journey on most people’s needs list. This is what needs to sink in with some excitable souls, who then need to move on.

      • Liz, wether or not the train is public transport is not what I am talking about.

        My point is the small group of people still opposing the train after more than 3 years need to move on. It’s not like this train happened overnight. They have had over three years to voice their opinions, but now almost five months after the service has started, it’s beyond time to let it go and move on.

        • Great reply Wayne. They do need to get over it and move on.

          Lee, if I’m not mistaken, aren’t you a frequent traveller on the train?

          Your facts are a little off too Lee. I’m sure all SEVEN fully qualified drivers would love to be getting $95,000 a year. But the facts are, they aren’t.

          Passenger numbers are also not your concern Lee. Why would it be? If you found a restaurant in Byron that was only getting 5 customers a night, would you go to all the effort of writing an article for the echo suggesting they close? No, because it’s their business. You should probably mind your own while your at it.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Far North Coast branch of NSW Farmers launches

The new NSW Farmers Far North Coast Branch, that will be representing farmers from the Tweed and Byron Shires, launched yesterday.

New Lismore refugee support group starting up

A local group from the Lismore area, the Lismore Region Refugee Settlement (LRRS), have come together to support refugees settling in the area. 

A tribute for Richard Moloney

Byron Shire has lost another of its colourful characters, the irrepressible Richard Moloney, who died suddenly but peacefully in his home at the end of January.

Flood rebuilds hampered by ‘like-for-like’ insurance clause

Attempts by flood-affected homeowners to retrofit their homes with flood-resilient materials are being cruelled by insurance companies and builders, a local resident says.