11.5 C
Byron Shire
May 24, 2024

2022 flood data quietly made public  

Latest News

New attractions for Mullum2Bruns Paddle

There’s new free activities to enjoy at Banner Park in Brunswick Heads after this year’s Mullum2Bruns Paddle, which will be held this Sunday, May 26, from 9.30am till 2.30pm.

Other News

Goonellabah Skate Park overhaul to start next week

New ‘skate elements’ to be introduced have reportedly been designed by skatepark specialists Trinity Skateparks, with input from ‘local enthusiasts’.

Stone & Wood wins at Australian International Beer Awards

Stone & Wood Brewing are proud to announce a big win at the Melbourne Royal Australian International Beer Awards held last night, with the brewery’s Big Pale Ale taking home the title of Champion Australian Beer. Big Pale Ale also took out the Best Australian Pale Ale category.

Homelessness service funded – but only for a year

With 2024 Street Count data indicating a 16 per-cent increase in rough sleepers in Byron Shire, the NSW government has responded to say that the previously-announced Assertive Outreach team will receive $1.3m in funding for a year.

Police appeal again to locate man missing from Mullumbimby

Police are again appealing for public assistance to locate Gage Wilson, a man missing from Mullumbimby, since Saturday, 18 May.

Danny’s world

Danny Wakil would have us believe that Israel is a sweet little peace-loving ‘sister democracy’ that can do no...

NSW gov’t opens Tweed Valley Hospital

The NSW government is to officially open the $723.3 million Tweed Valley Hospital today after the transferral of patients to the new facility last week.

The long-awaited state government analysis of the 2022 flood in the shire’s north is now available on the SES website.

It is called The Post 2022 Event Flood Behaviour Analysis – Brunswick River.

It was finalised in February 2024, and despite Echo requests over subsequent months, it was not released publicly by the NSW Labor government.

It’s unclear why there was no media release on this important document, which details flood heights and modelling from the most devastating flood in living memory. 

Council’s Floodplain Advisory Committee had been privy to the document, but were gagged from releasing it to the public.

Hydrologic modelling

The technical 115-page document was compiled by WMA Water for the NSW government, and draws on hydrologic modelling from various gauges across the shire’s north, including Durrumbul, Federation Bridge, Yelgun Creek, Billinudgel, Brunswick Heads and Orana Bridge. 

Peak 2022 flood levels were surveyed at Mullum, South Golden Beach, Brunswick Heads and Ocean Shores/New Brighton.

Remarkably, the flood data supplied by the public was not included as levels, only as deviations from modelled levels, according to longtime Council watcher, Matthew Lambourne. He sits on Council’s Floodplain Advisory Committee, and told The Echo that data from the public had been included in past reports.

Gauge is not accurate

Lambourne believes that Main Arm’s Federation Bridge gauge is not accurate. 

‘The gauge is on the on the downstream side of the bridge, and the flood level was higher, so an accurate flood height was not recorded’.  

‘[Regarding the data collected], ‘The difference between recorded height and modelled height was recorded’, he says, ‘but not the actual flood height’. 

‘All previous flood studies identified recorded and actual heights.

‘Obviously, the closer the levels between the two, the better. They are not all that close, particularly in Marshalls Creek, where it is off by an average of 200mm.

‘It’s been acknowledged that a new flood model is needed’. 

New model needed

While the report says on page 15 that ‘The current hydrologic model that covers the Brunswick River does appropriately replicate recorded flows and levels’, the authors also recommend that, ‘A full review of the Intensity–Frequency–Duration (IFDs) within the Brunswick River and Marshalls Creek catchment should be undertaken to ensure appropriate representation of orographic [position of mountains] effects’.

Recommendations 

Other recommendations include, ‘The design flow estimates at Durrumbul should be reviewed and updated as part of any future study; the hydrologic model should be extended to cover the entire Brunswick River system, including adjacent catchments which only interact in larger events; [and] the hydraulic model should be updated and extended to cover all areas that impact flood levels within the Brunswick River system, including adjacent catchments which only interact in larger events’. 


Support The Echo

Keeping the community together and the community voice loud and clear is what The Echo is about. More than ever we need your help to keep this voice alive and thriving in the community.

Like all businesses we are struggling to keep food on the table of all our local and hard working journalists, artists, sales, delivery and drudges who keep the news coming out to you both in the newspaper and online. If you can spare a few dollars a week – or maybe more – we would appreciate all the support you are able to give to keep the voice of independent, local journalism alive.

1 COMMENT

  1. Interesting to note that while the topping of the levee at SGB was referenced several times in the report, the Appendix D maps showing the peak flood levels indicate ZERO flooding for the western part of SGB. Not that I was holding my breath for any major revelation, but if this data and the maps they produced will inform future flood mitigation and emergency response, then I guess we will remain one of the forgotten parts of this shire. What a shame. Let’s hope the local SES know better.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Five hours spent at last Thursday’s Byron Council

If you need a fix of local government decision-making, you could dip into the odd five-hour online recording of what occurred at last Thursday’s Council meeting.

Editorial – Optics vs reform

One of the more hyped elements of last week’s federal budget was a $300 handout to every homeowner to alleviate the increase in energy costs.

Final kambo witnesses called, inquest yet to hear from Lore Solaris and Cameron Kite

The Jarrad Antonovich inquest ground inexorably towards its conclusion yesterday, with more evidence from witnesses showing the tragedy could possibly have been avoided, and certainly the ongoing damage lessened, if everyone involved had taken responsibility earlier.

A long story

I see that Israel supporters take exception to the expression ‘from the river to the sea’ as meaning that all Jews should be wiped...