17.6 C
Byron Shire
May 30, 2024

JRPP defers decision on West Byron development

Latest News

Kingscliff locals concerned over proposal to remove trees at Merve Edwards Fields for AFL

The potential of removing trees from the Merve Edwards Fields site at Kingscliff to accommodate the Kingscliff Junior AFL Club has raised concerns of locals and neighbours who say that this is not a proposal they support. 

Other News

Greener futures in Mullum

Byron Community College’s series of events with Mark Swivel continues to bring in a full house each week!

Photo of the week – 29 May 2024

Send to Letters Editor Aslan Shand, email: [email protected], fax: 6684 1719 or mail to The Letters Editor, The Echo, 6 Village Way, Mullumbimby, 2482, NSW, Australia.

‘Byron Independents’ ticket announced

Byron Shire Mayor Michael Lyon has announced his running mates for the upcoming local government elections. Cr Lyon will again contest the mayoralty, with Dr Meredith Wray, Cr Mark Swivel and former Councillor Jeannette Martin in the group.

Mullum2Bruns Paddle fills river with colour

An impressive array of aquatic craft took to the Bruns River on Sunday with participants taking part in the annual Mullum2Bruns Paddle.

Champion Australian beer

Stone & Wood Brewing, well known for their flagship Pacific Ale, have produced another winner, with their Big Pale...

A huge celebration in Byron

Stone & Wood’s 10th instalment of the Festival of the Stone is a celebration of music, community and ancient brewing tradition, to welcome winter to Byron Bay on Saturday. Byron locals and visitors will gather to take in a major line-up of music, tantalising tastes and the annual unveiling of the 2024 batch of Stone Beer, while raising much-needed funds for local homeless hub, Fletcher Street Cottage.

Opponents of the ‘local’ proposal for West Byron pack out Monday’s (October 8) JRPP meeting at Byron Council Chambers. Photo Chris Dobney

Chris Dobney

The Northern Joint Regional Planning Panel (JRPP) has deferred a decision on the controversial ‘local’ development application for West Byron, potentially leaving the matter to be decided by the Land and Environment Court.

JRPP chair and former National Party planning minister Garry West cited the lateness of hundreds of pages of changes from the developers, saying it left insufficient time for Byron Shire Council and the Rural Fire Service to make their assessments.

‘The applicant [also] made an application to vary the development standards – and that hasn’t been assessed by the Council, which is also a restriction,’ he added.

Mr West said that had the panel made a ruling it would have been ‘open to challenge in the courts’.

Three hours of speeches

At least 19 people took the opportunity to speak and more than 100 packed the gallery of the Byron Shire Council chambers on Monday afternoon (October 8) hoping this would be the end of the line for the much-maligned development.

Comments mirrored many of the previous concerns expressed at the JRPP’s ‘information meeting’ in June.

These included: the inappropriate scale of the development; the incursion into environmental zones; the impact on the Wallum Froglet and the koala at the site; the hundreds of thousands of tonnes of fill required, the likely flooding of surrounding properties in even moderate rainfall; and the impact on Ewingsdale Road of a six-metre sound barrier and some 14,000 additional daily car movements.

Members of the Northern Joint Regional Planning Panel and Byron Shire Council staff prepare for Monday’s (October 8) meeting. Photo Chris Dobney

Deeply frustrated

But, after almost three hours of speeches, Mr West told the meeting he believed a decision would have to be deferred, admitting, ‘we are all deeply frustrated but that is the only way forward’.

After some discussion, the panel, consisting of former bureaucrats Stephen Gow and John Griffin and neighbouring councillors Katie Milne (Tweed) and Vanessa Ekins (Lismore), reluctantly agreed.

Jeers erupted from the gallery, with residents shouting that that the entire process was a ‘disgrace’ a ‘farce’ and ‘a travesty of justice’.

One community member shouted that the introduction of late information, which many speakers argued contained no new facts, was ‘a typical ruse by developers to shut down community opposition’.

Panel member Katie Milne echoed the community’s frustration, at one point telling the meeting, ‘On the site visit we questioned whether we would be able to make a refusal today or not.

‘I don’t think the new information provided makes any difference.

‘Unfortunately, we have to [go through] proper process or we leave the community more in jeopardy than otherwise.

‘I hear your frustration – we’re all hearing the same.

‘The late submission of information has been very difficult for all of us,’ Cr Milne said.

Deemed refusal

Meanwhile the developers, including well known Byron Bay business identity Warren Simmons, have already taken Byron Shire Council to court for its ‘deemed refusal’ of their application even before the JRPP had the opportunity to consider it.

A mediation session is scheduled for February 12 next year and, if Council and RFS staff have not completed their assessments by then, the matter will be taken over by the court.

And, while that may still seem quite some time away, the second West Byron DA from Tower Holdings and Villaworld is due to land on planners‘ desks in coming weeks.

‘If we get to February 12, the role of the panel submerges into the court,’ Mr West told Echonetdaily after the meeting.

He added court-appointed conciliators could bring in outside experts to come up with solutions in the event Council and the proponents couldn’t agree.

‘If that fails… the court will take over the whole thing. The court has very wide powers,’ he said.

Court action defended

Stuart Murray, speaking on behalf of the developers, said they would be satisfied to see the matter deferred.

He was questioned by the panel as to why the landholders were suing the Council for deemed refusal before the JRPP had even met.

He replied that the proponents had taken the action because there was a ‘lapsing period’.

‘If we didn’t meet the deadline for lodging a deemed refusal, we might have to go through whole process again – so it was taken on advice of solicitors,’ Mr Murray said.

He was asked by Cr Milne, ‘if this was deferred and Council was able to keep working with you, would the court appeal be withdrawn?’

He replied only that he would ‘have to consult with the landholders’.

Support The Echo

Keeping the community together and the community voice loud and clear is what The Echo is about. More than ever we need your help to keep this voice alive and thriving in the community.

Like all businesses we are struggling to keep food on the table of all our local and hard working journalists, artists, sales, delivery and drudges who keep the news coming out to you both in the newspaper and online. If you can spare a few dollars a week – or maybe more – we would appreciate all the support you are able to give to keep the voice of independent, local journalism alive.


  1. Surprise, surprise, these developers are wealthy enough to tie the council up for years if necessary until they get what they want or near enough.
    Greed Rules


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Ballina Council to look into making tiny homes accessible 

The idea of living in a tiny home can seem like a simple solution to our housing crisis – but getting council approvals for a permanent tiny home on private land can be challenging. 

Council staff to look at limiting bulk and scale in Wategos  

A motion by Cr Sarah Ndiaye (Greens) to amend the LEP to reduce the building height limits in the Wategos residential area from 9m to 8m was unsuccessful at last Thursday’s Council meeting. 

Is this the next Bentley? New doco highlights value of Clarence River amid mining proposal

Mining plans for the region were discovered by two locals as they paddled down the Clarence River near Grafton. The question is what does it mean for the future of the Northern Rivers?

Editorial – Mining is back, baby! 

Nearly ten years ago in 2015, junior coal seam gas miner Metgasco was paid out handsomely – $25m of your tax money – after its approval to frack Bentley was fiercely fought off by thousands of well-organised protesters. But now they are back...