13.2 C
Byron Shire
July 7, 2022

Can residents be protected from the next heavy weather event?

Latest News

Value of the intangible and Suffolk Parks future

It’s hard to know what value to place on the environment – until it changes irrevocably.  A place is defined...

Other News

Road workers strike first time in decades

Road workers, construction crews and other Transport for NSW workers will walk off the job for the first time in decades on Thursday, as frustrations over the NSW Government's effective pay cut boil over.

Mandy Nolan’s Soapbox: To Hall and Back

There is something magical about a country hall. These small wooden buildings dot the landscape. They have a frugal modesty and an old fashioned generosity. If they had names they’d be called Thelma or Rose or Alan. They’re a pungent olfactory mix of last week’s wedding enmeshed with yesterday’s committee meeting. Curry and Jatz, tea and beer, tears and laughter.

Celebrating 40 years of Fig Tree Restaurant

It all started with a simple dream, to convert its original farmhouse in Ewingsdale into a restaurant in which...

Farmers: flood rebuild vital for regional survival

An increase in federal government funding to rebuild businesses in Lismore has been welcomed by the state’s peak farming body, but it remains concerned about vital job losses.

The wetlands questions for the new Council

The Northern Regional Planning Panel (NRPP) recently gave a determination for a Bioenergy Facility to be built within the...

Australian-first Surf Series and workshops ends in Lennox Head on Sunday

It might be cold outside but that's not stopping women who love to surf and over 100 women and girls will participate in the first female event series in Australia on Sunday at Lennox Head.

Capricornia Creek. Photo Good Earth.

Should Council reopen blocked and diverted creeks and ocean outlets in the Shire’s north to alleviate future flooding events?

That’s the push by Jan Mangleson, from the Ocean Shores Community Association (OSCA) as well as other residents who contacted The Echo. The recent flooding impacts could have been less, they claim, if the waters could drain to the sea via ocean in/outlets that were blocked in the 1970s.     

In the lead up to the second flooding event on March 27, Mrs Mangleson pleaded with Council to open the Capricornia Canal to ease flooding.

She wrote, ‘OSCA endorses the community lived experience over decades that the reintroduction of the overflow would lower flood levels at north and south Ocean Shores, South Golden Beach, New Brighton and Billinudgel’.

She says the ocean flood overflow was constructed by the developers of Ocean Shores in 1973, ‘as part of the development consent for the canal and the town’. 

‘Before constructing the permanent flood overflow, the developers, Princess Properties, cut a temporary slot through the dunes where, historically, floodwaters flowed to the ocean in major flood events and this was open between 1973–76 during the major floods of 1974’.

‘Because this temporary outlet cut a sand mining road used by local fishermen, Council ordered Princess Properties to block the outlet and reconstruct the sand mining road on 22/6/1976, but the developers warned Council they would be liable if the closure raised flood levels.

‘At the 27/7/1976 meeting, Council voted to accept the liability for the increase in flood height and the developers closed the outlet’.

Mrs Mangleson says, ‘Many locals are angry that the Capricornia Canal flood overflow was not opened before the February 28, 2022, flood disaster, which has caused so much destruction to homes.

‘Newcomers to the area had no idea of the extent of flooding in the area. A huge 400 metre long rock-wall constructed in the 1960s at the entrance of Marshalls Creek to the Brunswick River has prevented the outflow of floodwaters for more than fifty years, and has caused a buildup of siltation in the river.

‘A 30m gap exists for waters to enter the Brunswick River’.

So what do the experts say about reopening coastal creeks to lessen the impacts of heavy weather events?

Coastal engineer and former General Manager of Pittwater Council, Angus Gordon, is familiar with the region’s long history when it comes to coastal management.

Mr Gordon has been involved in Byron Shire’s coastal management for decades, having written papers and advised successive governments and councils generally on coastal management.

Historical summary

Aerial view of the canal. Photo OSCA

He told The Echo, ‘To the best of my recollection, the statement by Jan Mangleson is substantially correct, and a reasonable historical summary’.

‘I actually do have a good recollection of what happened, because I was asked about the “slot”, or more correctly the “fuse plug” through the dunes.

‘This was at the time the area was about to be developed, and flooding was a potential major impediment.

‘There was significant political pressure to enable the flood prone land to be developed (might have had something to do with a singing/owner, [Pat Boone], and his influence).

‘Initially, Public Works advised against the entire development, as it was fairly obvious that flooding in the area would be a problem.

‘I recall an early drawing showing the canal systems (and development) stretching further south to link up to the creek but the scheme was only partially built.

‘The compromise solution was to build the canals, but then to connect them to the ocean by a “slot” through the dunes, which would be kept closed, except during floods, so as to prevent oceanic over wash inundating the development.

‘I recall my comment at the time was that it wouldn’t work, because the likely dune recovery was such that it would be an ongoing management issue to keep the slot low enough, and small enough that it could be easily broken out to release the flood (hence the term “fuse plug”).

‘However, my recollection is that Council took little interest, or possibly didn’t understand the importance of this flood relief mechanism. Nor I guess, were they in a position to fund the ongoing maintenance the developers had saddled them with.

‘Apart for anything else, one problem with opening a “slot” through the dunes to relieve floods is to be sure that ocean levels aren’t as high, because in my experience, opening up such a “slot” can often promote oceanic flooding back into the developed area.

‘I do recall raising this at the time as being a potential issue, but I don’t recall it ever being studied.

‘In summary, the area of South Golden Beach should probably have never been allowed to be developed, because it is too low, and the only practical way to manage flood waters is down the creek to Brunswick Heads.

Flooding problem ‘insoluble’

South Golden Beach in flood February 2022. Photo OSCA.

‘The problem being that ocean levels with tides, wave set-up and storm surge, are likely to back-up floodwaters anyway, and certainly pose a risk if a “slot” is cut through the dunes.

‘Further, while I don’t think the Council actually understands the history or the limitations of the design, they also probably realise (from the North Byron Floodplain Risk-Management Study and Plan) that the flooding problem is insoluble anyway, as there just isn’t the hydraulic gradient to get the flood waters out under certain conditions.

‘So, the best answer is to elevate the houses where possible… they were originally meant to be de-mountable, and so should be easy to raise… but unfortunately, memories are short, and people, and councils, do “funny” things that result in “wicked” issues.

‘A study could determine whether or not opening a “slot” to the ocean would be advantageous, or the opposite, depending on oceanic water levels during storms, and at least the community and Council would better understand the problem… particularly with climate change and rising ocean levels.

‘Frankly, I suspect an education program for all might be a good starting point… as I said, it should never have been developed in the first place, I am afraid.

‘So, while OSCA is substantially correct in their historical analysis, I am not convinced they realise what the actual situation is.

‘I recently was engaged by Central Coast Council to deal with community angst regarding flooding of dwellings and properties around Tuggerah Lake. The community was blaming Council for not maintaining the entrance, and allowing it to close.

‘It was a relatively simple matter to demonstrate that the flooding they were experiencing was largely owing to the oceanic water levels during storms, and that they were being back-flooded by the sea.

‘So, council’s inefficiency at maintaining the entrance, had the unintended outcome of reducing peak flood heights!

‘State governments have, over the years, allowed development in naturally flood prone areas – the new NSW planning minister is even encouraging this…unbelievably.

‘The only workable solution is the Dutch one; build levees and put in pumps.

‘Big pumps’.

Calls for Plan update

The closed outlet at Capricornia Creek. Photo Good Earth.

Meanwhile, Mrs Mangleson says, ‘It is time for Council to reassess its Flood Plan’.

She said, ‘The Ocean Shores Community Association (OSCA) calls for data to be collected from this recent event, and data modelling to take into account the huge build up of siltation in the river, creeks, drains and lakes of the area’.

‘It is time effective mitigation has to occur, and funding made available to the Ocean Shores district for flood recovery’.

In August 2020, Council adopted its North Byron Floodplain Risk-Management Study and Plan.

While the Study’s authors acknowledge that blocking beach outlets and the creation of the Sandy Road from South Golden Beach to Wooyung contributes to flooding, the authors say unblocking the creeks ‘would not be effective’, and suggest ‘house-raising and flood proofing’, which ‘could significantly reduce the impact of flooding on residential properties’.

The Echo is yet to hear from Council staff as to whether the Floodplain Study and Plan will be reassessed, as per Mrs Mangleson’s request.

The Echo asked Cr Duncan Dey, who is a hydrologist, where Council’s North Byron Floodplain Risk-Management Study and Plan were at, in terms of the actions it outlined. Mr Dey replied that of the 24 actions listed in the Plan, only two have been funded. ‘They are the deflectors on Federation Bridge and Council’s emergency website dashboard’. 

‘I don’t think the Plan makes it clear enough that all measures fail for current floodplains at some time next century (or earlier) owing to sea level rise’.   

He added that various draft versions of the Plan ‘are not necessarily correct’, and sit among a huge string of PDFs on Council’s website.

Previous articleCouncil sprays again
Next articleWe got the BLUES!

Support The Echo

Keeping the community together and the community voice loud and clear is what The Echo is about. More than ever we need your help to keep this voice alive and thriving in the community.

Like all businesses we are struggling to keep food on the table of all our local and hard working journalists, artists, sales, delivery and drudges who keep the news coming out to you both in the newspaper and online. If you can spare a few dollars a week – or maybe more – we would appreciate all the support you are able to give to keep the voice of independent, local journalism alive.

7 COMMENTS

  1. (a) No more development & elevate flood proof all buildings now
    (b) Levees [dike] systems to be built

    Years ago I worked for an inground ‘swimming pool company’
    where concrete sides & floor were the norm. Many of these
    structures were near the sea & consequently large water-pumps
    had to be used to keep the tides at bay until the pool water was
    ‘pumped in’. Large steel structures held everything in place.
    Levees systems work a treat.

  2. The answer to your headline question , is NO!
    If you are living in an altitude of less than 66 meters, you are going to be inundated by the rising sea level, permanently, when the ice caps melt.
    Nothing has been attempted to reverse this ongoing process and it is now proceeding at an accelerating pace.
    This is deplorable but inescapable, now that we have decided not to take the warnings seriously or make any realistic changes, the coast-line is soon to be submerged, but even more importantly most of our agricultural land , along the coast but also all of the Murray /Darling and anything below 66 meters above sea-level all around the globe, if we can escape the inundation, we will starve .
    Cheers, G”)

    • If you are less than 66 meters, you will flooded by the year 2000. That was what the “experts” said.
      I pointed out when I was a kid that most of the ice on Earth is in the oceans. When ice melts, it shrinks, thus causing sea level to drop.
      Funny how they don’t factor that in to their calculations.
      It’s like climate “scientists” only get funding to produce fear porn.

      • As a kid, Chris that would be a good observation , however as most of the volume of stored ice is above land ,as in Greenland and the Antarctic, so of course this is factored in to calculate the average rise of sea-level , as is the fact that as the oceans warm the water expands.
        Neville C. thank you for your concern but rest assured, I would not contemplate any permanent structure below the forecast, and rapidly approaching rise in sea-level, now that all hope of limiting global warming to 1.5 degrees was doomed to fail due to inaction and government encouragement of the worst offending industries producing fossil fuels.
        Cheers, G”)

        • Ken and Nev, here’s a video you will both like. It’s about how climate change deniers like to hide historical data to push their agenda of hiding the extreme climate change.
          Goto youtube and search for “Big Trouble In The Little Ice Age”

          There are other good videos about the Egyptian cities that are now under water due to rising sea levels due to global warming. Search for that too.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Where is the love?

I have lived in Mullum and the surrounding hills for 35 years.  Yesterday I drove to Upper Main Arm, to Kohinur, to visit a friend,...

Flood help information from Chinderah, and Uki to South Golden Beach

The floods in February and March are still having direct impacts on the lives of many people and Serice NSW has a trailer coming to a location near you so you can easily access flood assistance.

Weaving through NAIDOC

DJ and Delta with some of the Weaving for Reconciliation exhibits. Photo Jeff Dawson.

Management of Byron’s fragile coastline impeded by NSW government: report

Insufficient funding and guidance from the State government is inhibiting Byron Council’s attempt to effectively manage its famous but fragile coastline, a Council report has revealed.