23.2 C
Byron Shire
November 29, 2022

Why are we building on floodplains?

Latest News

Rip Starters light up twilight cricket

The Rip Starters have played big hitting cricket to go to the top of the Byron Bay twilight cricket...

Other News

NSW Forestry challenged over failed forestry practices in precedent setting case

What makes bushfires worse, causes native species collapse and creates forest dieback? NSW Forestry is being challenged over its logging of Cherry Tree State Forest in the NSW Land and Environment Court.

Curious statements on Assange

The couple of letters under the headline of ‘In Defence of Julian Assange’ contained some curious statements in an...

From Margaret River to Byron to save veterans

William ‘Will’ Burnett served in the RAAF for ten years in logistics and ended his career as a well-established physical training Instructor. After his discharge, on his return from the Middle East, his mental health declined and he struggled through the clinical health system.

International Day for the Elimination of Gender-Based Violence and the start of 16 days of activism

Today marks the start of the 16 Days of Activism Against Gender Violence Campaign, a global campaign dedicated to ending gender-based violence.

Lismore raises awareness on World AIDS day

On World AIDS day, 1 December, ACON Northern Rivers Office and the HIV and Related Program Unit, are running a poster exhibition and trivia night at the Civic Hotel in Lismore.

Barrio now open every Sunday

If you’re already dreaming about the weekend, how does spending a long lunch at Barrio Eatery & Bar sound? Owing...

Flooding in Sydney during the July 2022 floods. Photo ABC

Brought to you by Cosmos Magazine and The Echo

And who’s responsible for the building?

Parts of New South Wales are being inundated for the third time in four months as yet more record-breaking rain causes flooding to Sydney and beyond. Add to this the March 2021 floods and it’s the fourth time in two years that some people have watched parts of their homes go under water.

Flood risk has been known to Sydney for nearly as long as Sydney as a European settlement has existed. In 1817, for instance, governor Lachlan Macquarie sent numerous letters warning colonists against building on floodplains. First Nations people have had tens of thousands more years to manage and avoid floods.

Climate change will only exacerbate this. So: why are we still building in the path of floods – and what would it take to stop doing it?

“People built on them in the past because there was quite a high degree of ignorance,” says Professor Jennifer McKay, a researcher in environmental management and business law at the University of South Australia.

This is no longer a good excuse, according to McKay. “No ignorance is possible of the scientific evidence about floodplains. Where there’s a floodplain, there will be a flood,” she says.

Now, the incentives for developers and local councils outweigh the perceived flood risk. Knowledge hasn’t stopped massive developments and influxes of people in flood-prone parts of Western Sydney, which now faces an overflowing Warragamba Dam and a subsequent rising Hawkesbury River.

“Prior to 2021 the previous big flood was 1990 – and this, to me, is the problem,” points out Dr Ian Wright, a senior lecturer in Western Sydney University’s School of Science.

“We’ve had 31 years relatively flood free – my criteria is there’s been no major floods, exceeding 12.2m at Windsor, which is the threshold for what is considered a major flood in the Hawkesbury.”

The three-decade gap, and the growth of Sydney’s population, means there’s little community memory of flood risk.

“Perhaps the height of bridges, or escape routes, hasn’t been top of mind of the community, industry or the elected leaders. It certainly is on top of mind now,” says Wright.

“Warragamba, in a day, has spilled pretty much what Sydney drinks in a year over this last weekend.”

So what should happen?

“The statutes in every state that enable development approval very rarely include the need for the potential area to be assessed for hazards, either fire or flood, and that’s what needs to change,” says McKay.

Development approvals are managed by the states, but McKay thinks there’s a role for the federal government to play too.

“The Commonwealth could step in here and create a law because they’ve got plenty of power. But obviously, it’s politically not expedient to do so,” says McKay.

Wright agrees, suggesting there’s space for such a law under the Environmental Protection and Biodiversity Conservation Act.

“I think a floodplain – and particularly the Hawkesbury-Nepean, which is also the water supply for five million people – that’s a matter of national environmental significance, so it slots neatly into legislation,” says Wright.

More on floods: Rebuilding for flood resilience

McKay adds: “We need to have a decent royal commission on this.

“We need to look at all the state laws, point out what’s wrong with them and get the federal government involved in getting the states to make sure that this issue is considered.”

The housing and rental market being what it is, a house built on a floodplain will still be lived in by someone – but they’re likely to be more economically vulnerable than people who can afford to live in less risky areas.

“Government should be looking at the longer-term, broader perspective, particularly for people who are deprived economically,” says McKay.

“Just letting the market send them to the cheapest places is going to create many more costs in the long run.”

This article was originally published on Cosmos Magazine and was written by Ellen Phiddian. Ellen Phiddian is a science journalist at Cosmos. She has a BSc (Honours) in chemistry and science communication, and an MSc in science communication, both from the Australian National University.

Published by The Echo in conjunction with Cosmos Magazine.

Support The Echo

Keeping the community together and the community voice loud and clear is what The Echo is about. More than ever we need your help to keep this voice alive and thriving in the community.

Like all businesses we are struggling to keep food on the table of all our local and hard working journalists, artists, sales, delivery and drudges who keep the news coming out to you both in the newspaper and online. If you can spare a few dollars a week – or maybe more – we would appreciate all the support you are able to give to keep the voice of independent, local journalism alive.


  1. The problem is that developers are allowed not-to-care about what might happen in the future AFTER they have sold their blocks.
    State governments and Councils need to be able to exercise PROPER planning, without fear of been taken to court, without taking bribes, without being accused of not providing sufficient land for construction.
    The entire system is corrupt and (mostly) the not-so-rich pay the price. This is today’s ‘Fair Go”!

  2. The longer-term is obvious… still ‘making a dollar’ wins every time.
    Laws are needed to stop the skimping. Simple, really.

  3. We are building on flood planes because of mass immigration in a relatively short time frame..
    The population has to go somewhere, and the cheapest land is the flood plane. Unfortunately we are now in the early stages of a Climate Catastrophe and flood planes are flooding more often and more severely.
    The sheer numbers of people needing housing overwhelms the planning system, corners are cut and proper assessment goes out the window.
    Next global heating will throw ocean level rises at us. Millions of existing properties will be threatened with inundation.
    Business as usual is not an option.
    We need housing that will protect us from flooding, severe heatwaves, super cyclones, and wild fires
    Building on and into the sides of hills ,hobbit fashion, would protect us from all the climate threats provided the hills are stable.

  4. Flood planes have ‘the last say’ & we’d best believe it. As for Land Swap realize
    assistance is needed – forget putting-it-on-hold because that is foolish as well.
    The way of the world’s incompetence is due to ‘the ways of mankind’ brought
    to slackness & the love of an easy buck. The sell-out is here to stay. Playing the
    game of numbers no longer works. This avoiding the obvious has got to stop.
    Think on it.

  5. Cosmos got it a bit wrong re flood and fire assessments .. Re floods, there is flood inundation mapping on the NSW coast and i would think state wide for decades which controls development approvals. Before that — we have a problem re existing settlement. Today the problem is councils, engineers and developers try to find ways to mitigate / engineer a solution. Obviously it doesn’t always work and big areas get flooded with an oh well, we tried — don’t sue us.! And with climate change here and predicted to be more extreme by scientists who have now studied the scenario for 50 years – there is a huge problem turning the Titanic around. The insurance industry is the first group manning the lifeboats, others will follow – – but there is not enough lifeboats for the people getting flooded — only a life vest in freezing water.

  6. In the end the solutions are always political — the system of dividing up power and resources. The general public has to take more interest in their lives and where the Titanic is taking them if they really want to survive the trip ! . .


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Cinema: Seriously Red

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z0RCj3-Pz50 If you’re a fan of Dolly Parton, then this just might be your happy place for the summer. Seriously Red is a rowdy and...

Strong winds and good tides set up a race day of fast sailing on the Tweed River

Matt Andrews with his trusty crew puts Powder Monkeys through its paces. Photo supplied. A big incoming tide and a sustained 20 knots of wind;...

Local tennis players bring home Wendy Saville Cup

Local tennis players Lachlan Johnson, Sylvie Peart, Marielou Baudouin and Onyx Cheong represented the North East region in the U/16 division of the Wendy...

Infatuating audiences

Byron Bay indie-rock outfit The Collifowers have made a habit of infatuating audiences all along the east coast with their high energy live show...