13.9 C
Byron Shire
September 27, 2021

Historic Alstonville trees saved as govt accused of ‘panicking’

Latest News

New venues of concern in Ballina

The Northern NSW Local Health District has been notified of a number of new venues of concern associated with a confirmed case of COVID-19.

Other News

NSW Regional Housing Taskforce to recommend holiday rental regulation changes

Regional Housing Taskforce Chair Garry Fielding says recommendations around short-term holiday letting regulations will feature in his report to planning minister Rob Stokes later this month.

Woman charged over alleged Public Health Order Breaches – Tweed/Byron

A woman has been charged over multiple alleged breaches of the Public Health Orders in the Tweed and Byron shires.

Water resilience

A number of groups in the Byron Shire have been working our way each month through topics set for...

Long COVID and the science, so far…

Increasing COVID-19 vaccination rates as quickly as possible is currently a major focus for Australia.

Biggest corporate greenwashers revealed by Greenpeace

According to a new analysis by Greenpeace, most of Australia’s highest-emitting companies that have implemented net-zero emission commitments do not have any will to meet their target.

Lismore coming out of lockdown

At midnight tonight (Wednesday 22 September) lockdown will be lifted for the Lismore local government area (LGA).

Alstonville resident Ian Cooke, who led the charge to save historic trees in the village, believes the state government wasted millions cutting down trees across the state because it 'panicked'. (Darren Coyne)
Alstonville resident Ian Cooke, who led the charge to save historic trees in the village, believes the state government wasted millions cutting down trees across the state because it ‘panicked’. (Darren Coyne)

Darren Coyne

A community campaign to save nine historic fig trees in Alstonville has highlighted a massive waste of money by the SW government.

Trees in schools across the state were lopped on the orders of the NSW Education Department following the death of Sydney schoolgirl Bridget Wright in February this year.

More than 5,000 trees were removed at a cost of $13 million but opponents say a review of the removals found justification for the removal of just 20 trees.

Alstonville resident Ian Cooke, who led the charge to save the fig trees at Alstonville Public School, which are located on the boundary with St Joseph’s Primary School, said bureaucrats and politicians had simply panicked.

“In my opinion it’s a sin to remove any healthy tree on this planet,’ Mr Cooke told Echonetdaily.

‘These nine historic fig trees provide a huge amount of shade and parents were concerned that their removal would leave the school children without adequate shade during the hot summer months.

Mr Cooke said 1,400 people signed a petition to save the trees but NSW education minister Adrian Piccoli had not even bothered to respond, or investigate anomalies that had been pointed out in reports from arborists.

Instead, as a final resort, an injunction was sought and granted in the NSW Land and Environment Court on the day contractors arrived to remove the trees.

NSW Land and Environment Court Justice Rachel Pepper overruled the department, citing inconsistencies in the reports used by the government to justify the removal of the Alstonville trees.

Mr Cooke said an aborist in a 2013 report had concluded that the risk of harm was 1 in 1,200,000, while a second report a year later said the risk was one in 62,000, or 20 times greater than the initial report.

Mr Cooke said if the minister had considered the differences in the reports there would have been no reason to take legal action.

He said the Alstonville win should give confidence to other communities trying to save historic trees.

‘I like to think people in other communities who have trees they regard as community assets should ask a few questions. And if you can’t get the right answers there’s always court,’ he said

‘And the NSW education department should first consult with parents and citizens before making decisions to remove trees,’ he said.

Mr Cooke also said the department should instigate a monitoring program for trees on school grounds to identify potential risks.

“It was a freak accident with the girl in Sydney and our research showed that it the first time in NSW that a child had been killed by a tree,’ he said.

‘We believe it was a panic situation. Bureaucrats and politicians like to cover their bums.’

Support The Echo

Keeping the community together and the community voice loud and clear is what The Echo is about. More than ever we need your help to keep this voice alive and thriving in the community.

Like all businesses we are struggling to keep food on the table of all our local and hard working journalists, artists, sales, delivery and drudges who keep the news coming out to you both in the newspaper and online. If you can spare a few dollars a week – or maybe more – we would appreciate all the support you are able to give to keep the voice of independent, local journalism alive.


  1. Good, I’m glad the trees were saved. Knee-jerk reactions to a few isolated incidents are becoming all too common. Like re-arranging streets and signage because drunk drivers can’t negotiate a corner.

  2. Couldn’t agree more with Jon’s comments. Trees are part of nature and whether they are in the forest, streets or school yards they serve a purpose. What are the school kids going to think when we start chain sawing them ?


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Byron Bay beach party end in PINS and a charge for biting

Police say a woman has been charged and four Penalty Infringement Notices (PINs) issued following a beach party in the Byron Bay area overnight.

Fundraising for koala signs for Bangalow

As the koala mating season has started, Bangalow Koalas has set up fundraising to create incorporate more koala road signs. Bangalow Koalas, who keep a watch...

Nuclear Submarines – just a foot in the door

In the next few months we will hear a lot about how superior nuclear-powered submarines are. Vice Admiral Mike Noonan is even claiming superior stealth characteristics – which is simply not true. Yes, they tend to be faster. This is great if you want to go thousands of kilometres in a matter of days. But they are also much more expensive.

Compost back on Lismore’s gardening menu

Lismore City Council says that their BIOCycle Compost is again on sale from the Lismore Recycling & Recovery Centre and Nimbin Transfer Station, after a two-year break.