26.9 C
Byron Shire
January 17, 2022

Role of health minister in selection of Tweed Hospital site questioned

Latest News

The earliest unequivocally modern human remains in Africa

There may be earlier remains of modern humans – but science is certain about these ones.

Other News

An unexpected vote for two Rous representatives from Lismore Council

Last night the new Lismore City Council voted for two Councillors to represent Lismore on Rous County Council, even though the agenda was clear that Rous County Council voting had been excluded owing to the requirement for a minimum nomination period of 21 days.

Lismore’s Australia Day Ambassadors

Ahead of the Australia Day celebrations Olympians Kaarle McCulloch and Kevin Chavez have been announced as Lismore’s 2022 Australia Day Ambassadors.

What do you do next if you test positive to COVID?

With more than a third of callers to the National Coronavirus Helpline asking about isolation, healthdirect has launched a guide to help those who are COVID-19 positive know what they should do while isolating at home and when to seek medical help.

776 cases of COVID-19 in the Northern Rivers in last 24 hours

There’s no shortage of positive COVID-19 cases in the Northern NSW Health District with the current count likely to be an underestimation of the numbers due to the overwhelmed testing capacity.

Stop Forestry Corporation causing ‘serious and irreversible harm’ to burnt out State Forests

A leaked report revealed that the independent report from the Natural Resources Commission’s to the NSW government to stop logging areas hardest hit by the Black Summer bushfires had been ignored.

Southern Cross University awarded almost $2 million for innovative research

Southern Cross University has received more than $1.94 million in government funding for innovative research at the institution.

Questions over the role that health minister Brad Hazzard played in ruling out the current Tweed Hospital site for redevelopment have been raised by Tweed Shire councillor Chris Cherry. Questions have also been raised in the NSW parliament this week by Greens health spokesperson Dawn Walker MP.

‘As a councillor, I was involved in the community group feeding back to Health Infrastructure during the extended time for consideration of alternative sites,’ said councillor Cherry.

‘The community had identified Kings Forest, Chinderah and the current Tweed Hospital site for further investigation.

‘After we had given the three preferred community sites as alternatives to examine, Health Infrastructure said the Minister had ruled the current Tweed Heads hospital site out. Brad Hazzard had said no. They did a basic comparison but didn’t look at the site properly as an option.’

The fertile red soil of Cudgen. Photo supplied.

MP Dawn Walker has said in parliament that the government are ignoring their own development strategies. 

The government’s own North Coast Regional Plan identifies the growth precinct for the region’s health services at the current Tweed Hospital site, yet they continue to ignore their own strategy and build the new hospital on the precious red soils of Cudgen Plateau’, she said.

‘In March 2017, less than three months before the announcement of the new hospital, there was no mention of the new development in the region’s Local Health District board meeting. The minutes note that they were awaiting formal confirmation of fully funding the redevelopment of the existing Tweed Heads Hospital. It’s clear that something has gone astray.’

Councillor Cherry believes that the siting of the new Tweed Hospital has become a political football rather than a process looking for the best solution for the region and the community it serves.

Commenting on the Tweed Hospital community reference group’s final feedback meeting with Health Infrastructure, councillor Cherry said, ‘What is disappointing is that they had already made a decision. We asked at the meeting about when the Minister would be making the decision, and Health Infrastructure representatives said they “were not at liberty to say”, yet they had obviously alerted the Tweed Daily News about their decision that afternoon.’

Denied by HI

Health Infrastructure have denied the allegations, telling Echonetdaily that, ‘A robust assessment process of over 50 sites was undertaken, informed by advice from independent expert advisors and the whole process was overseen by an independent probity advisor.

‘The recommendations from the assessment process were endorsed through the project governance structure prior to the minister for health confirming the selected site,’ said a Health Infrastructure spokesperson.

‘The recommendation that the “brownfield option” should not be shortlisted due to a number of deficiencies against the assessment criteria was endorsed through the project governance structure and did not involve the minister in any way.’

Government ignores calls to redevelop the existing site

While Labor have come out in favour of the Kings Forest site the Greens have moved a motion calling on the NSW Government to redevelop the existing Tweed Heads Hospital at Tweed Heads.

There is a lot of infrastructure built around the current site,’ said councillor Cherry.

‘A lot of people have settled there to be close to the hospital. This is a decision that will impact a lot of people’s lives.’

However according to Ms Walker ‘the minister for primary industries has confirmed in parliament that the government are ploughing ahead with site acquisition and the planning application process for a new hospital at Cudgen, despite acknowledging that it’s categorised as State Significant Farmland under the Northern Rivers Farmland Protection Project 2005.

‘It’s appalling that the National Party have sold out local farmers with their plans to concrete over the fertile farmland on the Cudgen Plateau and push for intense development on our food producing land,’ said Ms Walker.

Support The Echo

Keeping the community together and the community voice loud and clear is what The Echo is about. More than ever we need your help to keep this voice alive and thriving in the community.

Like all businesses we are struggling to keep food on the table of all our local and hard working journalists, artists, sales, delivery and drudges who keep the news coming out to you both in the newspaper and online. If you can spare a few dollars a week – or maybe more – we would appreciate all the support you are able to give to keep the voice of independent, local journalism alive.


  1. There was no mention in March 2017….
    OK then in April there were massive floods in 2017 – the whole regions flooding data got re-written (as has Gold Coast region in mid 2018) – this resulted in expected sea level rise and climate change flooding to be 0.8 metres higher than previously thought.

    This new data – all but eliminates the current hospital site at Tweed Heads – sorry GREENs – do you believe in climate change and scientists and experts??? – don’t lie I know you do. You just facts mean nothing in this debate.

    If the soil is so important – why dont the government offer it free to any Tweed resident to come and take to have a veggie patch in their backyard? then this soil transplant will mean the soil is not dead and veggies are still grown – but we have a new hospital also. I put my hand up to go get some of that soil. Thousands more would too if it is free before the concrete gets poured on that ONE location.

    No other land is hopefully going to be rezoned – lets not exaggerate this debate. It has only been about finding one flood free location for a new hospital

  2. The NSW Government is simply trying to move The Tweed Hospital as far south of the Queensland – NSW border as possible to eliminate patients coming from the southern Qld Gold Coast and thus reduce costs.
    Cross border issues have plagued our area for more than thirty years.
    My colleagues attended meetings for 25 years to enable blood supplies from Red Cross ( an Australia wide facility) to come from Brisbane to Northern NSW instead of from Sydney to enable rapid appropriate availability of blood products for patients. It was only in about 2013 the Red Cross and health representatives finally allowed this change. This decision was finally made when ” Red Cross realized it was less costly to move the blood products from Brisbane rather than Sydney”.

    The siting of the new hospital is all about reducing patient numbers. TTH has the busiest Emergency Department in NSW outside Sydney.

    The old Southern Cross University site across the road from TTH could have been purchased cheaply as a development site for TTH, but the Shire Council took the site……
    The Council requirement for two large multi-storey car parks to be built on the SE and NW corners of the current site also reduced the available space for building new blocks of operating theatres, wards, ED, Pharmacy, Radiology, Pathology etc.

    And does anyone really believe the Government will spend $534,000,000 on a hospital as close to Byron & Murwillumbah as Cudgen, especially when this will reduce patient numbers from SE Qld?

  3. Did the Tweed Hospital flood in those floods in 2017….NO….I hate to say it the Greens are right redevelop the current Tweed Hospital….the majority of Tweeds population is on the north side of the Tweed River…and it will continue to be the case as far as population estimates go out ….2036. Dont forget Cobaki Lakes is going to be massive

  4. It only takes minor to medium flooding before the Cudgen site will be isolated from the major populations of Tweed Shire, including Tweed Heads. Not bright planning for emergency infrastructure.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

The Greens launch NurseKeeper for nurses and paramedics

The Greens have written to the Premier to ask him to immediately introduce ‘NurseKeeper’ to urgently introduce pandemic pay and bonuses for nurses and paramedics. 

Lung specialist ‘we’re doing the best we can’ and Hazzard lays it on the line for the unvaccinated

At this morning's COVID-19 update press conference, Concord and Nepean Hospitals lung specialist Dr Lucy Morgan gave an update on COVID-19. Dr Morgan says she works as part of a team of people looking after patients with COVID.

Lismore’s Australia Day Ambassadors

Ahead of the Australia Day celebrations Olympians Kaarle McCulloch and Kevin Chavez have been announced as Lismore’s 2022 Australia Day Ambassadors.

Northern Rivers Animal Services needs helpers

Ballina-based animal welfare organisation Northern Rivers Animal Services Inc is on the lookout for cat-lovers to help at their cat cottage, and foster carers for both dogs and cats.