14.9 C
Byron Shire
May 26, 2024

Thus Spake Mungo: Coalition’s negging doubts continue

Latest News

Surfing on the spectrum – free fun for everyone at Lennox and Byron this Sunday

Ocean Heroes will be giving children who are on the autism spectrum the chance to experience what it is like to be in the ocean on a surfboard this Saturday at Lennox Head and Sunday in Byron Bay.

Other News

The 2024 budget wash up

It's impossible to make everyone happy on budget night, but Treasurer Jim Chalmers' 2024 effort has upset more than most, as the government struggles to avoid inflation rebounding, make more things in Australia, and do something about the cost of living.

Posters gone

I am writing to bring attention to a growing issue in our community – the removal of community posters....

Housing: too important to leave to private market

It saddens me every time I get to the back of The Echo and see all the real estate...

NSW gears up for humpback migration with expanded disentanglement team

An expanded team of specialised rescuers are poised and ready to launch as tens of thousands of majestic humpback whales begin their annual migration along the NSW coastline.

Garry Simes racks up 25 finishes at Australia’s oldest ironman triathlon

Ballina Triathlon Club member Garry Simes has achieved the milestone of finishing the Port Macquarie Ironman Australia race, one...

Shambolic roads

With regards to the Echo article, ‘Let’s dive deep into potholes’ (May 15), I am appalled at the attitude...

Neg can be an abbreviation of either negative or negligible, both terms the vociferous critics from left and right have used to denigrate Malcolm Turnbull’s masterwork in progress.

But for the hapless Josh Frydenberg, charged with the task of delivering the deformed infant, neg means negotiate – compromise, tweak, dicker, quibble, whatever it takes to produce an outcome.

And frankly any outcome will do as long as it can be spun as a solution to our self-inflicted energy crisis – certainty for investors and consumers.

Of course it doesn’t have to be certain for very long; the next election, which Christopher Pyne assures us will be in next May, will do for the moment, and then we can get back to negging the NEG. Who said you can’t nunscramble negs?

Turnbull and Frydenberg would much prefer to just bully their way through with carrots and sticks – bribery and threats if you want to be honest about it – as is their usual path through the chaos of the senate crossbench. But alas, the senate is certainly the last and may well be the least of their problems, the main one is, as so often, the bloody constitution.

The hard reality is that for all the bravado, the federal government has far less power over energy than it would like. It can and does set a national emissions target, which the Labor states (and everyone else who is serious about climate change) regard as hopelessly inadequate, but when it comes to the really tricky bits, the states and even the lowly territories decide, essentially, how the day-to-day administration of energy policy will be implemented – or not.

So it only takes one of them to veto the NEG in its current form – which is precisely what they have done. Time for more negging.

But like so many of Turnbull’s grand nimble schemes, this one has had to be placed back on the backburner: the states, reasonably enough, refused to sign off on a half-baked scheme which could easily be unpicked in the coalition party room.

It is all very frustrating for the feds, who had hoped to remove the albatross from their collective necks as soon as this week. The idea was to get conditional approval from the states, whip it through the party room past the coal fetishists and persuade them not to cross the floor while it can be barrelled through the House of Representatives and then assume that the senate will play ball.

But like so many of Turnbull’s grand nimble schemes, this one has had to be placed back on the backburner: the states, reasonably enough, refused to sign off on a half-baked scheme which could easily be unpicked in the coalition party room.

So the timetable has been rejigged: first deal with the party room and do a bit of hard negging there. And when and if the Abbotistas and their like can be persuaded to see the wonder and beauty of the creation, go back to the states, with the final (?) blueprint which is then to be displayed for scrutiny for four long weeks.

And this is where the crunch comes, because very shortly after that the Victorian government goes into caretaker mode for the state election, and when that is out of the way we have the silly (well, sillier) season, followed shortly by the New South Wales election and then, of course, the big one: the federal poll, which Turnbull can no longer avoid.

So effectively the NEG has to be passed by September, or not for quite a while. And given the almost hysterical build up to the event, failure is not an option, which is why Frydenberg will have to keep negging – it is no longer about the science, if it ever was; it is all about the politics.

As such, it will never produce an optimum result, and was never really intended to. There may be a drop – probably temporary – in consumer prices, but there may perhaps be an increase. There could be less blackouts, but this will depend on individual events – natural disasters of one kind or another will increase due to the influence of global warning, and given the influence of the denialists of the hard right, nothing can be done about that without provoking outright rebellion.

But most importantly, whether or not some version of the NEG is finally enacted, the long running climate wars, which have now been subsumed into the wider culture wars, will remain. If there was any doubt about that, step forward (or perhaps backward) Tony Abbott, who repeated his threat to cross the floor over the issue, just because he can. For a fleeting moment he has become politically relevant again and he intends to make the most of it.

So even if the premiers eventually succumb, the real crunch will come in the parliament – as it should. Turnbull rightly says that a large majority of his party room has endorsed his NEG, but if the rump who haven’t pursue their mission to destroy it, what the majority want does not matter: if a few of them are ready for open warfare, Turnbull is at real risk of losing a vital vote in the House of Representatives, with potentially fatal consequences.

As we know our timorous leader is not a risk taker. But withdrawing the legislation would be almost equally disastrous; the prime minister has invested virtually all his remaining political capital in the scheme. To salvage it he may have to plead with Bill Shorten to provide the numbers – a terrible humiliation but the only option left.

If it comes to this, Shorten may or may not agree, but will certainly string out the tortuous process for a few days of unbridled gloating. This will have to be the mother of all negs.

Coincidentally there is yet another definition of negging, an urban slang term which Wikipedia defines as: an act of emotional manipulation whereby a person makes a deliberately backhanded compliment or other flirtatious remark to another person to undermine their confidence and increase their need of the manipulator’s approval.

Sounds just like the job for a lawyer-banker, which Malcolm Turnbull certainly is, rather than a politician – which he certainly is not.

Support The Echo

Keeping the community together and the community voice loud and clear is what The Echo is about. More than ever we need your help to keep this voice alive and thriving in the community.

Like all businesses we are struggling to keep food on the table of all our local and hard working journalists, artists, sales, delivery and drudges who keep the news coming out to you both in the newspaper and online. If you can spare a few dollars a week – or maybe more – we would appreciate all the support you are able to give to keep the voice of independent, local journalism alive.


  1. NEG? When it comes to Fizza and his floundering Govt, NEG can only stand for “No Energy Guarantee”!
    To think otherwise is simply yet another contrived LNIPA delusion, ask yourselves, “What has Fizza and the LNIPA ever been right about, anytime, anywhere, ever”? 38 negative news polls and counting, tick tock, tick tock Fizza!

  2. Still the nagging question: are we really aware of what is happening? The reality of a Green future is playing out across the academic divide. Renewable energy will eventually have to mean controls, apportioning, rationing. We just haven’t been brainwashed enough for that yet. Sure it’s a conspiracy theory. So why are the greater number of environmentalists trained mainly in public relations?

  3. Culture wars … or in other words the hopes and aspirations of Fabians. You try to find scientific discussion pro or anti climate change on the Net and you get view points carefully worded to discriminate and stifle discussion. The real culture war at task is the upending of science and creation of one more religion in the world. Orwell could never have been so good to predict this, though he did in seeing the potential for history to be rewritten on a daily basis. In this case, it is politics, economics and, alas, science at the hands of beurocracy.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Wardell landowners asked to support fire ant eradication

Nearly 900 Wardell properties require treatment for fire ants, but the eradication team needs permission from each landowner.

The Darling Muffs of May need your help to reach fundraising target

Raising money to support frontline services for women who are homeless or at risk of homelessness has been the driving force behind the Darling Muffs of May’s fundraising this year.

Why does Iron Gates developer get another bite at the DA?

Locals, concerned residents and other parties were left in the dark for the first 15 minutes of the Iron Gates (Goldcoral Pty Ltd) Land...

Death and Dying expo May 25

On Saturday May 25, a free Death and Dying expo will be held at the Mullumbimby Civic Hall from 10am-2pm.