22.1 C
Byron Shire
October 4, 2022

Comment: Time for another Police Royal Commission? 

Latest News

Alstonville takes out top tier of the Oceania Cup

The Oceania Cup delivered exciting and close football for the 19 teams that competed across last weekend at the...

Other News

Ballina council taking suggestions for Lennox Head plan

Anyone with ideas for improving or protecting particular parts of Lennox and Skennars Heads has until 28 October to let the Ballina Shire Council know.

Lismore City Bowlo and all that jazz

What Lismore needs more of now is fun and joy and music and the Lismore Jazz Club’s popular monthly gigs are about to return to help make that happen.

Dreaming of Midsummer

Byron Ballet Company is currently preparing for one of the world’s most beloved ballets, A Midsummer Night’s Dream. This...

Acid sulfate soil run off impacting health of fish and Tweed River

Acid sulfate soil (ASS)-related runoff from floodplain drains is affecting water quality and the health of fish in the Tweed River and Tweed Shire Council (TSC) are seeking to assist landholders with improving water quality projects. 

Bioenergy facility funding rejected

Mayor Michael Lyon is downplaying a funding rejection for Council’s much touted Bioenergy Facility proposal by a federal government agency, claiming other funding sources are available.

On Save the Koala Day conservationists all agree they disagree with the Minister for Environment

Ahead of today’s Save the Koala Day, NSW Minister for Environment James Griffin yesterday announced that private landholders are being supported to restore 200 hectares of koala habitat in the Northern Rivers.

The mid-1990s Royal Commission into the NSW Police Service uncovered evidence of entrenched corruption, which included state law enforcement officers selling heroin out the back of police stations, involved in running then illegal sex work services and trading in child pornography.

Also known as the Wood Royal Commission, the inquiry’s six volumes of findings served to clean up NSW police operations, with outcomes including the decriminalisation of sex work, drug law reform and the establishment of a state police oversight body.

Justice James Wood headed the first Royal Commission into the NSW Police Force. Image: AAP

But, according to Redfern Legal Centre senior police accountability solicitor, Samantha Lee, it might be time for another investigation into the NSW Police Force.

Yet, this time, the police conduct under the microscope would be alleged overreach in terms of the application of certain powers.

‘It’s time to think about whether another Royal Commission is needed in NSW to look at how much the powers are going beyond the legislative framework and the cultural demise of the police force in NSW over the last few years,’ Lee told Sydney Criminal Lawyers.

The solicitor further asserts that what’s been happening in this regard constitutes a ‘bleeding out’ of police powers, specifically in terms of strip searches, drug dog use, the policing of the pandemic and the now defunct quota system.

These days, people living in NSW are faced with the prospect of being indicated by a drug dog on the street, in a pub or on entering an event, like a music festival.

And if a pat down search doesn’t turn up anything, they can then be asked to strip naked in front of two armed and uniformed strangers.

The Wood inquiry didn’t scrutinise these practices, as, back in the 90s, they didn’t exist as they do in the present.

Sniffer dogs didn’t become a part of everyday life in this state until 2001, while the heightened use of strip searches started to become apparent circa 2014.

The stated purpose of NSW police deploying drug dogs is to combat drug supply.

But since the release of the 2006 Ombudsman report, it’s been widely understood that dogs falsely indicate two-thirds of the time, and if a search is successful, it usually turns up a small amount of cannabis.

The coupling of the dogs with strip searches has been steadily increasing since mid-last decade.

In 2018, 11 percent of those indicated by a dog were subjected to this invasive practice. Yet, numerous reports outline that the effects of strip searches are similar to the impacts of sexual assault.

Lee went on to outline that strip searches were never meant to be used for minor drug possession, and, as the force itself admits, neither were sniffer dogs.

But it’s not just this misapplication of strip searches and sniffer dogs that’s causing the controversy around NSW police.

Indeed, there have been countless complaints and official investigations into officers overstepping the mark to the point of illegality in applying strip searches.

This not only includes breaching the legislated protocols, but police management advises that certain questionable procedures be used.

Another approach taken by NSW police that’s been scrutinised is that taken to public protest.

Whilet bolstered by the increasing anti-protest laws being passed by the NSW Liberal Nationals, it was the mid-2020 surge in the Black Lives Matters movement that brought this issue to a head.

In the aftermath of the first lockdown, the NSW police commissioner attempted to have BLM rallies shut down by the NSW Supreme Court, presumably as they had a focus on police conduct.

But when such actions did go ahead they were accompanied by saturation policing and excessive use of force.

This was followed by a crackdown on post-lockdown protest in general, which was facilitated by a clause in a public health order, and boiled over at Sydney University. Officers, again, employed excessive force to nonviolent student activists, and it only ended when officers turned on a professor.

Climate activists 

Of late, NSW police has turned its attention to climate activists.

Strike Force Guard was established to target climate defenders last March. And some of its actions have led to charges of overreach in relation to its staking out protesters, visiting them at home, multiple raids, arresting individuals days after protests, and the storming of an activist picnic.

Lee puts the stark rise in NSW police use of strip searches down in part to its quota system. Since at least 2018, police local area commands had been operating under a system of quotas in terms of the number of searches and move on order officers were required to carry out annually.

Then NSW Greens MLC, and now Senator David Shoebridge obtained the statistics relating to this system in late 2019, via freedom of information (FOI). And he stressed that the scheme clearly opened up ‘the use of both these police powers to serious abuse’.

First published at www.sydneycriminallawyers.com.au. You can see the original post here.

Support The Echo

Keeping the community together and the community voice loud and clear is what The Echo is about. More than ever we need your help to keep this voice alive and thriving in the community.

Like all businesses we are struggling to keep food on the table of all our local and hard working journalists, artists, sales, delivery and drudges who keep the news coming out to you both in the newspaper and online. If you can spare a few dollars a week – or maybe more – we would appreciate all the support you are able to give to keep the voice of independent, local journalism alive.


  1. Why on Earth do we need another investigation in to the police ?
    Every time they are investigated the findings are the same , they are corrupt , they are vicious thugs, they ARE organised crime and represent the greatest threat to peace and democracy in society.
    Police are an army of mercenaries designed to maintain the right-wing status quo and protect those with money or influence, while pocketing a hefty slice of criminal profits. Our crooked politicians rely on them for protection , and the courts ensure their immunity from prosecution.
    Always has been , always will be,
    Cheers, G”)

  2. No comments ! I wonder if this reflects on the story of policer abuse and apparent score settling … what do you think?

  3. Yes definitely time for another Royal Commission into the Police Service. Difficult really to call the police when you need help, you may get someone corrupt, and their corruption is more than likely condoned

  4. In Byron I experienced BLM protestors were left alone whilst police harassed and fined freedom protesters both in the same time frame/rules by gov

    • I would have thought ‘ BLM protesters’ exemplified freedom protestors , so I wonder what manner of protestors even the police determined were undesirable.
      Cheers, G”)


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Great waves on offer for the Evans Head Malibu Classic

The 30th annual Evans Head Malibu Classic was run last weekend with clean one metre-plus waves on offer right across the four days of...

Ocea Curtis takes third place at national qualifier in Merewether

Lennox Head surfer, Ocea Curtis, has finished third in the U/16 girls division of the Grom Search National Qualifier held at Merewether Beach over...

Todd Woodbridge Cup to be held in Byron Bay

Tennis NSW, along with Byron Bay Tennis Club is hosting the regional qualification event of the Todd Woodbridge Cup on October 14 at the...

Dreaming of Midsummer

Byron Ballet Company is currently preparing for one of the world’s most beloved ballets, A Midsummer Night’s Dream. This original creation of Shakespeare’s evergreen...