20.4 C
Byron Shire
December 2, 2024

Mullum’s future water supply still uncertain 

Latest News

This wonderful town

As the commerce/tourism interests get excited about the need to get the place lit up like a Christmas tree...

Other News

An ode to Mexico

Come and celebrate the grand opening of Zócalo’s new shop in Newrybar next week!

Lismore investigates asbestos dumping

Since the 2022 floods there has been an increase in the illegal dumping of asbestos in the Lismore local government area (LGA) with several asbestos dumping investigations taking place. 

Northern Rivers volunteers up for NSW awards

Communities from across the Northern Rivers region are being urged to get behind their local volunteer finalists for the 2024 NSW Volunteer of the Year Awards.

Investigation underway after multiple break and enters

Police have commenced an investigation into a number of crimes in Brunswick, Byron Bay and Goonellabah involving a pursuit with a stolen vehicle.

Byron Council apologises for data breach

The Byron Shire Council has apologised for a data breach last week that resulted in the publication of phone numbers, home and email addresses for 32 Byron Shire residents online.

Tell us a little about yourselves – who you are, where you’re from and what sets your soul on fire?

Hi, we’re Jessie & Tom – the lovers, makers and founders behind Azteca Margarita. Azteca, like Tommy, is made in...

Lavertys Gap Weir. Photo NSW Office of Environment & Heritage

What is the best way to secure a long-term, reliable water supply for Mullumbimby?

This question has been batted around for years within Byron Council, but took on extra significance and urgency after the 2019–20 drought and bushfires, when the water supply for the town reached critically low levels.

Yet, more than three years on from the fires, the right solution is still the subject of debate within Council, and no action has been taken.

One point that most can agree upon is that Mullumbimby’s current water source, the ageing Lavertys Gap weir in Wilsons Creek, is not a viable long-term option in its current state.

Council reports show that demand for water in Mullumbimby is basically equal to the amount that the weir can sustainably supply in normal rainfall conditions.

With the town’s population forecast to grow significantly over the next decade, and climate change putting paid to any reliance on consistent rainfall, there is a very real risk the town could run out of water if an alternative source is not found.

It is predicted that, if Mullum continues to rely on Lavertys Gap without modifications, demand would exceed supply by 37 megalitres per year by 2050.

Council staff say that Lavertys Gap weir is having a significant negative impact on the surrounding environment, and that the water treatment plant it flows through is no longer up to the task of providing a quality water supply.

The question of what to do about this remains a highly-vexed one.

Council staff argue that Mullumbimby should follow the rest of Byron Shire, and move onto the supply from Rous Water, the organisation responsible for water management across the region.

They point out that the infrastructure already exists to make this happen, in the form of an emergency line that the town made use of in 2019, and that this is the only viable way of guaranteeing a long-term water supply for the town.

But the members of Council’s Water and Sewer Advisory Committee disagree as do Water Northern Rivers (WNR).

The Water and Sewer Advisory Committee do not believe that Rous Water can be relied upon to deliver an environmentally sustainable water supply into the future, pointing to the organisation’s periodic support for a dam at Dunoon which, if constructed, would flood huge areas of farmland and native habitat.

‘Rous Water is an entity unto themselves, and I don’t feel that they have environmental considerations high on their agenda,’ said Greens Councillor, Duncan Dey, who is a member of the committee as well as a professional hydrologist.

Cr Dey and his fellow committee members argue that modifications can be made to Laverty’s Gap weir to help it form part of a sustainable supply. This includes fish ladders, environmental flows and building a large water storage tank to back up the weir. 

A broader supply solution also includes other water sources, such as the groundwater system at Tyagarah, and improved rooftop water harvesting.

‘Within that committee, there’s real expertise, and we all agree that diversity of water sources is a really healthy model,’ Cr Dey said.

‘Having a singularity of sources is not a good plan.’  

Water Northern Rivers point out that a connection of Mullumbimby to the Rous Water grid and disconnecting the Lavertys Gap supply ‘would be a retrograde, unsafe, expensive and unpopular step’.

‘The Dunoon Dam (DuD) will probably not go ahead due to numerous insurmountable problems,’ said WNR spokesperson Nan Nicholson. 

the Widjabul mob showing their opposition to the DuD. Photo Larissa Roberts

They highlight the recognised and significant Indigenous cultural heritage sites that would be drowned as well as ‘the loss of highly significant natural heritage, especially koala habitat and the Endangered Ecological Community of Lowland Rainforest (part of the last one per cent of the Big Scrub).’

Cost blow out – $220M to $815

The increasing, and some say prohibitive, cost estimates for the dam are also another issues raised by WNR. 

‘The cost of the dam has increased from $220 million, as modelled by Rous’ consultant Hydrosphere, to $815 million according to the DPE, if additional connections as made,’ points out Ms Nicholson. 

‘The state government is unlikely to finance the dam which leaves it to the rate payers to bear the huge burden of rate hikes. Mullumbimby residents would be paying through the nose to enable unrealistic growth in Ballina and Byron coastal zones.

‘The Strategy’s cost/benefit analysis of the dam found no economic benefits over costs when climate modelling was applied.

‘There is very poor social licence for the dam and if it went ahead there is likely to be severe social division which would reflect poorly on Byron Council. The residents of Mullumbimby have been in the forefront of opposition to the DuD and this would be a betrayal and an unfair financial burden.

‘If Mullumbimby becomes committed to Rous’ water it would leave the town with an even greater water problem.  Byron Shire Council needs to increase diversity of supply and reduce demand on Rous’ water.  Connecting Mullumbimby to the Rous grid would do the opposite.’

At this stage, the two sides appear to be at an impasse.

A special workshop is planned before it goes to Byron Council in late April or May.


Support The Echo

Keeping the community together and the community voice loud and clear is what The Echo is about. More than ever we need your help to keep this voice alive and thriving in the community.

Like all businesses we are struggling to keep food on the table of all our local and hard working journalists, artists, sales, delivery and drudges who keep the news coming out to you both in the newspaper and online. If you can spare a few dollars a week – or maybe more – we would appreciate all the support you are able to give to keep the voice of independent, local journalism alive.

4 COMMENTS

  1. Unfortunately the security of Mullumbimbys water is now in 2023 not 10 or 20 years away. Remember the 2019 drought and the severe water restrictions? Remember after the flood we couldnt use water because the infrastructure was damaged and they trucked in water to keep the town going not to mention bottled water at the flood centre. Theres nothing ‘special’ about Mullum which makes it necessary to have an independent water supply. Connect it to Rous. Staying independent is an expensive option council litterally can’t afford. Perminant rous connection will have a low cost because the water delivery pipe is already built. The water is safe and will have long term security because rous will diversify water harvesting sources

    Cr Dey let the professionals at Rous make the important water security decisions for the community. It is well above your pay grade and outdated hydrological knowledge.

    Time is not on mullums side so stop playing political games. Cr Dey sometime it’s okay to be wrong.

    • Logical really, good post Anon.
      I guess ‘diversify water harvesting sources’ could have something also to do with making new dams.
      To reduce the impact of flash-flooding, small “reserve” ones on creeks could be instituted, to lessen the surge-effect with cyclonic falls.

  2. Your article ‘Mullum’s future water supply still uncertain’ briefly mentions the issue of supply and demand but then devotes all its attention to supply. Sooner rather than later attention must be devoted to demand which is driven principally by population growth and this is driven by the present government, with the support of the Liberals and the Greens, pushing the highest rate of population growth ever in Australia – 300,000+ from immigration. Numerous recent polls have shown that between 70 and 75% of Australians want either a smaller population or one that does not grow further. No political party raised this issue before the last federal election quite deliberately denying Australians an opportunity to vote on this issue. A balanced article on the supply of any item taken from Nature must raise the issue of demand and hence population growth.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Electoral system

Australia needs an independent electoral system inquiry. In discussions on TV, Senator Don Farrell, preparing the final report on the 2022 federal election, stated that...

Rubbish collection

My twin sister Jane and I ‘enjoy’ walking around town picking up all the ‘small to medium’ rubbish in Bruns and Mullumbimby. I thought maybe...

Contradictions and self-interest

In The Echo (13 November 2023) there was a proposal to redevelop Byron’s Main Beach car park, etc (page 5), a warning on climate...

Men charged over arson and ram raid of Tweed and Ballina tobacconists 

Two men have been charged over the three incidents of arson and ram raiding at the Tweed and Ballina tobacconists.