18.4 C
Byron Shire
June 25, 2021

Who dobs on the dobbers?

Latest News

Tweed still waiting for action on shark safety

Frustration at the lack of action in relation to sharks and beach user safety in Tweed Shire is clear as Council wait for the state government to follow through on their shark mitigation strategies.

Other News

Byron Council’s Draft Climate Change Adaptation Plan on exhibition till June 28

A five-year draft Climate Change Adaptation Plan is now before the public.

Localisation debate

Helena Norberg-Hodge, Byron Bay In describing localisation as my ‘pet hobby horse’, Boyd Kellner (Letters, 16 June) reveals a fundamental misunderstanding...

Tim Watkins’ killer sentenced

The driver who hit and killed a young man in a hit and run two years ago has been sentenced.

Michael Lyon announces Byron Shire Council ticket

Byron Shire Mayor, Michael Lyon, has announced a group of candidates to run for the upcoming Council elections in September.

Adani continues case against Pennings, has major investors withdraw, and hits first coal

It has been quite the week for Adani with the striking of their first coal at the Queensland Carmichael...

The knives are out

Paul Brecht, Evans Head Reading the letters section of The Echo I came across the two councillor’s Martin and Ndiaye...

Andrew P Street

Back in August 2016 – oh, it was a different time! – Treasurer Scott Morrison was talking about Australia being a nation of ‘the taxed and the taxed-nots’, the latter group being those so gosh darn fortunate to be [checks notes] living so far below the poverty line as to not reach the threshold to pay any income tax.

And aside from it being deliberately and provocatively cruel to suggest that wealthy people paying tax were doing it harder than people on unemployment benefits, it was also a lie: no matter how far below the threshold someone might be, they’re still paying tax any time they buy underpants or half-fill their petrol tank or pay a phone bill or do anything else that attracts GST.

However, the childishly nasty tone of Morrison’s whining criticism definitely made clear to anyone wondering if Morrison was concerned about the welfare of those actually on welfare, that the answer was, and remains, a thundering ‘Nup’.

Employer Reporting Line

And now, many years down the track, we have the sight of his best pal and current Employment Minister, Stuart Robert, fresh from the triumph that was the courts finding Robodebt to be completely illegal, merrily introducing the Employer Reporting Line – aka DobSeeker – where would-be employers can report dole recipients who lied on job applications, refused an offer of work, or quit after a short time in employment.

For the record, the current mutual obligations for most unemployed folks involves applying for 20 jobs a month – jobs which, depending on the bit of the country you’re in, either don’t practically exist or don’t even exist in the realms of fantasy.

In fact, there’s a solid argument that this requirement alone acts as a disincentive for potential employers to advertise positions at all because it’s just not worth the HR hassle of handling literally thousands of applications from people who aren’t remotely a good fit but need to hit their monthly quota in order to get an amount of money on which they can’t realistically live.

Rampant levels of wage theft, bullying, and sexual harassment

And given the research that has been carried out over the last year or so in the fruit picking and hospitality industries, which have discovered rampant levels of wage theft, bullying, and sexual harassment, it’s great that the government has now created a way for dodgy employers to weaponise their power even further against anyone who might consider running for the goddamn hills when they realise what they’ve signed up for.

Mind you, if you’re agog that Morrison and Robert would be in favour of a system that will potentially force young women to remain in dangerous workplaces or face official consequences, especially in the wake of Brittany Higgins’ alleged rape in a ministerial office, then you might want to sit down before hearing exactly how necessary the government’s draconian new system actually is…

According to figures presented by ol’ Stu in senate estimates last week, the current number of welfare recipients being investigated for non-compliance is 352. The number of people actually found to have breached their compliance obligations is eight.

And the number of people on benefits that require compliance? Just under 1.3 million.

In other words, the DobSeeker hotline has discovered – at massive public expense, and hundreds of workhours from Centrelink employees – that a terrifying 0.000006 per cent of recipients have breached their mutual obligations in the last four months and change.

Value for taxpayer money

And just to be clear, this isn’t about ensuring value for taxpayer money. Not even Robert could spin the numbers to suggest that the public wasn’t spending orders of magnitude more than it could ever hope to claw back from the hands of people doing it tough.

Now compare and contrast with the money splashed around for JobKeeper, including the much-reported $22 million given to Harvey Norman, which they declined to return despite reporting pandemic profits of $462 million.

Did Morrison demand the funds be returned from them and the many other profitable companies that accepted JobKeeper? Or suggested that giving public money to shareholders and management breached the company’s obligations to the taxpayer?

If you guessed ‘No, I bet he was openly dismissive of the question,’ then give yourself a pat on the back. When asked in parliament about the situation, he declared ‘I have always said that is a matter for those companies… I mean, I would rather have profitable companies than non-profitable companies.’

The deserving and the deserving-nots

Morrison’s wealth-based division between the deserving and the deserving-nots was also on show in his reticence to offer support payments to Victorians left without work from the current lockdown, and his stern admonishment that handing over money for people to live on when their places of business were forced to close will… um, somehow, incentivise an entire state to sneakily spread viruses about?

In any case, this must be a huge comfort to everyone in lockdown wondering where their next meal might come from, or dreading the near-certainty that accepting their pandemic payment will result in a future Robodebt letter of demand, signed by Stuart Robert’s printer.

But that’s how life will continue, as long as we have a prime minister who openly misrepresents the struggles of Australians in penury as people choosing to live in poverty as some sort of tax dodge.

Andrew P Street. Photo Daniel Boud.

Andrew P Street

Bestselling author, columnist, all-round word-ordering person.

T: #AndrewPStreet
W: https://patreon.com/andrewpstreet

Support The Echo

Keeping the community together and the community voice loud and clear is what The Echo is about. More than ever we need your help to keep this voice alive and thriving in the community.

Like all businesses we are struggling to keep food on the table of all our local and hard working journalists, artists, sales, delivery and drudges who keep the news coming out to you both in the newspaper and online. If you can spare a few dollars a week – or maybe more – we would appreciate all the support you are able to give to keep the voice of independent, local journalism alive.


    • ‘President ScamMO’ aka ‘Teflon Man’, can scarcely believe his luck. On his watch there been many and massive failings but the punters in general don’t give a shite, they just keep voting for their ‘President ScamMO’. Rorts, Scams, Incompetent Governance, all the specialities of ‘President ScamMO’ and he is rewarded by his ‘Quiet Australians’. You really have to wonder what goes on in the minds of ‘The Quiet Australians’. How Good is Australia, yeah.

    • The delusion is all President ScamMO’s. The dude reckons hotels are fit for purpose for quarantine when patently they are not. He spits out his 99.9% bang on job being done but ignores the effect of those 22 Covid leakages out of hotels. The hotels were an emergency go to quarantine when Covid first arrived. We are 14 months down the Covid quarantine track and we coulda, shoulda, woulda built those required fit for purpose quarantine stations. But no, President ScamMO not interested, like everything else he doesn’t care, doesn’t take responsibility, even when the job belongs with Federal Government. But yeah Barrow my man, keep plugging away with your support for gold standard President ScamMO.

  1. The ‘quiet australian’ will stick his fingers in his ears – scratch the back of all lust-for-lifers
    who spit on anyone who doesn’t believe that God & Jesus alone selected our hand-picked
    ruler. Most women are for-warned that being a male’s plaything is the best they can

  2. The best turnaround in economic history
    and all you absolute Muppets ever do is
    F complain ..seriously why dont you all move to a country preferably China where you will be arrested for such views or opinions.. and take that National Broadcaster with with ..
    We live in the best country in the world Pre or post covid .. 100s of millions of people the world over would lose a leg to come and settle here .. spoilt entitled sliver spoon fed
    Individuals.. !! Deport yourselfs ..

    • Barrow why bother to post reason in a such a hard Left rag filled with the same type of people.
      Mungo never could see any good in this side of government and was cheered on by the readers

  3. Oops. I had a dream [eg; nightmare] that I was already in China. All the cover-ups are the same
    & money’s as free as a bird for those in the know.

  4. Plenty of plain and simple facts here seem to be getting the ‘voters’ at odds over which “new’s” (or even views) are the real ones!!
    Yes we are certainly on the way to China or is that the other way around (National security censorship)??? Glad we have some who still can express freely, for the moment anyway.

  5. A question never answered. The safest place [because there weren’t any others] could
    only have been… you guessed it – hotel quarantine. The PM said so. Andrews didn’t
    believe that early in the piece & stamped out ‘fit for purpose stations’ that the dear Gove
    thought was expensively stupid. Months later Dan got his way. We haven’t lived
    happily ever after but those who may have died now expect the right to be here in
    the flesh. And, naturally, the ABC had the guts to call for safe harbors. Talking about
    deports is pretty dumb seeing as how we’ve been proven right most of the time.
    Yes. Lest we forget. I wont.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

42 lots given tick by Council for Myocum

Plans for a 42-lot residential development in Myocum have taken a significant step forward after Byron Council agreed to enter into a voluntary planning agreement (VPA) with the owners of the site.

Byron Music Festival so successful you can already get tickets for next year

Last weekends Byron Music Festival was a sold out success say organisers. 

Tim Watkins’ killer sentenced

The driver who hit and killed a young man in a hit and run two years ago has been sentenced.

Life aquatic: Franck’s big underwater adventures

Diving under the ice caps and photographing the mysterious twilight zone was the culmination of a childhood dream for Byron-based Franck Gazzola.