13.8 C
Byron Shire
May 22, 2024

Byron Council wins landmark court case against developer

Latest News

We Like to Tiki: Caper festival closing party this Sunday

North Byron Hotel is the official watering hole of Caper Byron Bay Food & Culture Festival 2024. To celebrate...

Other News

The Fall Guy

Ryan Gosling and Emily Blunt are being silly in a film take of the ‘80s television series: The Fall Guy. He’s a stuntman, and like everyone in the stunt community, he gets blown up, shot, crashed, thrown through windows and dropped from the highest of heights, all for our entertainment. And now, fresh off an almost career-ending accident, this working-class hero has to track down a missing movie star, solve a conspiracy, and try to win back the love of his life while still doing his day job. What could possibly go right?

Lost in pronunciaton

Ivan Aristeguieta is ridiculously funny. What’s better is watching people try and pronounce his name – and then of course, it’s his deep dive into Aussie culture. Ivan has lived in Australia for ten years – as he says ‘living amongst you, observing you, learning about you’ – and now he makes a very good living taking the piss out of you. ‘I am a true blue, dinky-di Venez-stralian. Nah, she’ll be right! (Who is she by the way?).’

Feudalism alive

The increasingly restrictive parking at New Brighton shows feudalism is alive and well. It is understandable – wanting to protect...

Contraband, Chile’s 9/11 and black ops 

Putting the life of local adventurer Chris Dewhirst into print would be no easy task. But he’s managed to do it, in part, with Everest Guns & Money.

Rally in Byron against Gaza war

Locals are being called to join in a rally at Byron Bay this Saturday at 2pm calling on the Australian government to take action against the deaths of Palestinians in the invasion of Gaza by Israel. 

Outdoor pickleball courts for Alstonville

Alstonville now boasts tournament-standard pickleball courts that opened to an enthusiastic crowd and players earlier this month. The eight new...

Belongil landowner John Vaughan addresses council (October 30, 2014). Photo Eve Jeffery.
Belongil landowner John Vaughan addresses council (October 30, 2014). Photo Eve Jeffery.

Hans Lovejoy

Should councils be responsible for a developer’s loss of expected earnings if their development application (DA) is rejected?

In what appears to be a precedent for the nation, leave to appeal to the High Court has been refused, upholding the right of councils to reject such claims.

According to Findlaw’s legal service report, it’s good news for councils around the country, ‘because it confirms that when councils are exercising statutory functions, such powers are unaffected by a duty owed to private interests, including those of developers.’

Staff advise appeal avenues exhausted

A recent memo to councillors from senior staff reads, ‘The claim against Council by Dansar Pty Ltd (Mr and Mrs Vaughan) is now over as all avenues for appeal have been exhausted. The claimant will be liable to pay the council’s (Council’s insurer’s) costs of the High Court as well as all prior proceedings.’

Mr and Mrs Vaughan are two of a handful of Belongil residents who Cr Sol Ibrahim says will help fund rock wall structures to protect their homes.

The Echo understands that a previous council erected rock walls in front of Vaughan’s property, which created a legal liability requiring them to be maintained.

However, the unrelated negligence claim by the Vaughans against the council goes back to the period of the sewer moratorium from 1997 to 2006.

At the time, development required ‘prior adequate arrangement’ owing to a lack of council facilities to cope with human waste.

The applicant’s claim arose from the council’s failure to properly manage the council’s development application process due to the council’s sewerage system nearing capacity, which resulted in the development application initially being rejected.

According to special counsel Karen Browne and law graduate Andrew Clements, ‘In 1997, council resolved to limit the number of new developments approved in the area due to the limited capacity of its two sewerage treatment plants.’

‘The council’s planning controls prevented it from approving development applications unless the council was satisfied that prior adequate arrangements had been made for the provision of sewerage services to the land proposed to be developed.

‘In 2001, Dansar Pty Ltd (the developer) applied to the council for development approval to carry out a residential development. At the time of application, there was sufficient capacity in the sewerage system for the development. However, the council failed to correctly calculate the capacity of the sewerage system, which resulted in the developer’s application initially being rejected.

‘The developer re-submitted its application, which was approved by the council in 2005. The developer claimed that but for the council’s error, development approval would have been granted in a timely manner.’

Developer’s claim

‘The developer commenced proceedings in 2007 claiming damages from the council for a breach of a common law duty of care allegedly owed to them.

‘The developer claimed that the delay in approval was largely caused by the council failing to exercise reasonable care in carrying out the task of allocating the spare capacity, which it had determined should be allocated to new developments.

‘The developer alleged that the council owed a duty of care to the developer to ensure that it did not suffer economic loss resulting from the council’s refusal or delay in implementing its decision.’

First Sun Park approved

John Vaughan told The Echo, ‘Dansar believed the minority position in relation to the specific issue “duty of care” in relation to the allocation of a scarce resource being allocated by a monopoly authority “the council” was correct. Dansar’s application was the only application refused a sewage allocation of about 35-odd applications, pre and post March 2001.

On February 13, 2002 Council staff, without the delegated authority to do so, invoked Clause 45 of the Byron LEP.

‘In March 2002, Council staff defended the appeal on that basis, ie there was no spare capacity or a least not enough for Dansar’s application. Mr Warner, on behalf of council in the Land and Environment Court, gave evidence that has proved [incorrect], saying the STP was overloaded, in that case one example below.

‘It is worth noting that council approved the expansion of the First Sun Tourist Park including building backpacker accommodation and further tent sites on newly leased State Rail land in April 2002, without any concerns about an overloaded West Byron STP.

‘Before the recent Supreme Court appeal in 2013, counsel for Byron Shire Council belatedly admitted that at all relevant times, sewage capacity was available for Dansar’s application!

‘Council had resolved to allocate 89 Kl in September 2000, and did not alter or amend that resolution.

‘At no time did the actual “council” resolve to impose Clause 45, a fatal clause of the Byron LEP on Dansar’s DA.

‘In fact they had deliberately removed Clause 45 from staff’s recommended reasons on December 18, 2001.

‘In the execution of that resolution, council staff made numerous undefended errors and only allocated in total about 60 Kl of the resolved 89 Kl, including an allocation to Dansar’s via second application, approved some three years or so after the original application could have been approved on February 22, 2002, but for sewage allocation. Dansar will not have the opportunity to ventilate the clearly inequitable and ultra vires council staff’s decision before the high court.

‘If a council has no “duty of care” in the allocation of a scarce resource what might flow from that decision?

‘It surely leaves open the possibility of discrimination in an allocation process.

‘In Dansar’s case, it did not get an allocation on February 2002 and council itself approved the expansion of the First Sun Park in April 2002 and added to the flow to the STP. Go figure.’

Council staff were asked for comment but none was recieved by the time of going to press.

Refutes friendship claim

Mr Vaughan also says that regarding a recent Echo story where Donald Maughan claimed to have seen him man Cr Ibrahim’s election polling booth, he says he is ‘not a friend of Cr Ibrahim’.

‘I have only emailed him on issues of concern as one of the councillors when communicating with council.

‘It is my usual practice to cc councillors when writing to the general manager.

‘As to the assertions by Mr Maughan, he is clearly confused – I was handing out election material for the Woods team, which is my democratic right to do.’


Support The Echo

Keeping the community together and the community voice loud and clear is what The Echo is about. More than ever we need your help to keep this voice alive and thriving in the community.

Like all businesses we are struggling to keep food on the table of all our local and hard working journalists, artists, sales, delivery and drudges who keep the news coming out to you both in the newspaper and online. If you can spare a few dollars a week – or maybe more – we would appreciate all the support you are able to give to keep the voice of independent, local journalism alive.


  1. How good is this! Thank heavens the courts can see past this developers rhetoric. At last some small savings for ratepayers in the Shire. Now let’s look again at those rock walls!

  2. John Vaughan must have “rocks in the head” to litigate against this council action. Money and sheer arrogance blinds people to the seeing the real outcomes. Enough ratepayers money and council time have been wasted by this man. Memory loss appears to be a problem as he was observed by others handing out Ibrahim’s election pamphlets on council election day.

  3. If council did not have to spend so much money on court proceedings they might be able to afford to update the present sewage system

  4. I checked the Austlii site re case law in NSW (austlii.edu.au/) for previous cases between Vaughan/Dansar & BSC – I found 12 cases from1998. This must be a record for any individual in Byron Shire. Imagine the total cost to ratepayers. Now even the High Court has found against Vaughans/Dansar – dare we hope this will be the last?


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Spice Palace: a mecca for Middle Eastern dips and spice mixes

Victoria Cosford The business was a natural fit for Bec and Tom, new owners for the past few months, of this successful little operation.  Spice Palace,...

Byron Rebels continue strong run in local rugby union

The Byron Shire Rebels put on 83 unanswered points against Lismore Rugby Club last weekend at Shultz Oval, capping a good day for the...

Garry Simes racks up 25 finishes at Australia’s oldest ironman triathlon

Ballina Triathlon Club member Garry Simes has achieved the milestone of finishing the Port Macquarie Ironman Australia race, one of Australia’s premier events, for...

Outdoor pickleball courts for Alstonville

Alstonville now boasts tournament-standard pickleball courts that opened to an enthusiastic crowd and players earlier this month. The eight new tournament-standard outdoor courts have been...