18.9 C
Byron Shire
March 30, 2023

Iron Gates developers roll out the big guns at conciliation meeting at Evans Head. Community says ‘NO’

Latest News

Is polluting a lake in a national park to support new housing ok?

From Byron Bay to Evans Head to Casino the questions about how we deal with what is politely termed ‘effluent’, and how that may or may not destroy our local environment, demand real and urgent answers.

Other News

Rosebank’s Rainbow Temple referred to the Land & Environment Court

Lismore City Council say they have referred the Rainbow Temple in Rosebank to the Land & Environment Court after the owner repeatedly declined to submit a Development Application and associated documentation for the development.  

Janelle Saffin holds the seat of Lismore

Janelle Saffin is in the lead for the seat of Lismore after yesterday's state election. Although preroll and postal votes are yet to be counted, it’s hard to imagine Saffin’s position changing.

$200k in grants available for local not-for-profits

The inGrained Foundation has announced a $200,000 funding pool for the 2023 Northern Rivers Large Grants Program, opening this April.

Share flood stories at Mullum Farmers Market

To mark the anniversary of the 28 February 2022 flooding of Mullumbimby, which was followed by continued flooding throughout...

No chance of change

Sadly, David Heilpern’s well-written missive regarding non-compliant dog owners in Byron Shire will achieve absolutely nothing. The fact is,...

Women of song at The Con

The Northern Rivers Conservatorium (The Con), in association with Musica Viva Australia, is pleased to present a special event in its Concert Room on Friday 28 April – Women of Song.  This innovative new show developed by the acclaimed Jessie Lloyd of Mission Songs Project includes themes of intergenerational practices, singing on, and from, Country, commitment to community, and preserving knowledge in song. It’s an intimate celebration of the ‘here and now’ of Indigenous culture, a rare mix of spontaneous conversation and songs exploring the modern-day practice and living heart of the world’s oldest living culture.

The L&EC banned photos at hearings. Locals waiting to speak before the L&EC hearing.

Iron Gates is an approximately 50 hectare site at Evans Head that has been subject to proposed development applications (DAs) since the 1980s. The local community has repeatedly highlighted the flood and fire risks of the site as well as held developer Graham Ingles to account for illegal clearing of the site through the courts.

The site is once again back in the Land and Environment Court (L&EC) for a Section 34 Conciliation Conference following the rejection of a DA by the Northern Regional Planning Panel (NRPP)on 7 September, 2022 that highlighted two independent reports stating that the DA should be refused. The conciliation conference was convened at the Iron Gates property at Evans Head on Monday morning (6 March, 2023) to consider the decision of the NRRP to refuse the DA from Goldcoral Pty Ltd for residential development on the property.

Simone Barker (nee Wilson), daughter of the late Lawrence Wilson who opposed the development back in the 1990s accompanied by supporter Jaydn.

The conference was attended by staff of Richmond Valley Council and Council’s solicitor, Simone Barker from Bandjalang Traditional Owners and members of her family, represented by her solicitor. There was also a large phalanx of legal representatives and experts hired by the appellants Goldcoral Pty Ltd (in external administration), a substantial number of residents opposed to the development, and L&EC Commissioner Michael Chilcott who presided over the conference.

Michael Chilcott, L&EC Commissioner. Photo www.LinkedIn.com

The commissioner indicated that he had only come to the file last Thursday.

Six locals addressed the commissioner

Dr Richard Gates from Evans Head Residents for Sustainable Development Incorporated said that he found it ‘passing strange’ that he should be addressing a conciliation conference of the L&EC having not been told what the grounds for the appeal from Goldcoral Pty Ltd were. He said that nonetheless, any matter involving proposed residential development at the Iron Gates site demanded comment so that the court was very clear that residential development was not welcome and that should it proceed, it would knowingly put people in ‘harm’s way’. He said that the land should be rezoned to a more environmentally-sensitive zoning in keeping with its character, something the community has been asking for for many years. 

Dr Richard Gates.

Dr Gates also said that he found it difficult to reconcile the fact that land along the Woodburn-Evans Head Road had been recommended for removal from residential development status in Richmond Valley Council’s draft Growth Management Strategy, while almost identical land to the south of it, the Iron Gates site, was still included for a large residential development.

Dr Gates also covered fire and flood risks for the Iron Gates site pointing out from his own experience as a volunteer firefighter, as well as chair of an advisory committee involved in fire plans for National Parks, and park ranger and planner in Canada, that it was difficult to understand how the RFS had given approval for residential development on the site. Dr Gates queried their assessment processes, particularly in view of climate changes now upon us.

Measurements made of each of the Iron Gates sites using the ‘area measuring tool’ from SIX Maps. While the R1 zone makes up a majority of land within two of the blocks (276-277) it occupies only 40 per cent for the three blocks which are the subject of the DA, highlighting that much of the land is not zoned R1. The L&EC banned photos at hearings.

He pointed out that the land is also subject to serious flooding: ‘why else would the developer dig two huge canals hundreds of metres long?’ Dr Gates also reminded the commissioner that the 2014 flood planning maps are incorrect and two of the three are missing from the assessment process.

Dr Gates highlighted that the NRPP was in error drawing the conclusion that ‘much of the land proposed for development’ was zoned R1 Residential when measurement showed that it was approximately 40 per cent with most of the rest being of environmental (see image).

Elaine Saunders who spoke at the NRPP Hearing and again at the Land and Environment Court Conciliation Conference.

Commissioner Chilcott also heard about many other issues of concern from the community including impact on the koala population from Maria Matthes, Aboriginal cultural landscape integrity matters and history from Jocelyn Reese from the Bundjalung Nation and Elaine Saunders from Evans Head Residents for Sustainable Development. Ms Saunders also included information about the 1895 destruction of the land bridge at Iron Gates which joined the north and south sides of the Evans River together allowing passage of the Aboriginal Nation for important cultural practices.

Protest at the time Iron Gates Drive was being bulldozed through Crown Land circa 1991, 30 years ago. Photo supplied

Dr Peter Ashley spoke particularly to the status of the Iron Gates Road, built illegally across wetlands to get to the property, and for which Richmond Valley Council claims no responsibility, and the matter of who the appellants were in the conciliation meeting, which is not known to the public. He asked whether the court might be interested to know who it was as there was information ‘on the street’ that it was foreign-owned. Ian Rankin spoke on the impact of the development on the local community and its infrastructure and the isolated nature of the community. There was no support for the development from any of the speakers.

Public excluded

Once the six speakers were heard by the commissioner, the meeting was adjourned and all the parties, except for the public, moved to the Iron Gates property where the conciliation process continued. The commissioner indicated that once the site visit was completed the parties would reconvene at the Casino Council Chambers but that the public was excluded. The outcome of the conciliation process would be provided by Council’s solicitor.

A large contingent rolled up on behalf of the developer Goldcoral and their silent investors. The L&EC banned photos at hearings.

Effect of money and power on display

Dr Gates said that it was interesting to observe just how many people Goldcoral Pty Ltd had rolled up for the conciliation. Such a large contingent suggested money and power. ‘I expect they would be collecting information about what the community had to say. Hopefully they got the message that the Iron Gates development was not wanted and was dangerous.’

Dr Gates said that he expected that the case for appeal would go beyond the Section 34 conciliation process to the court itself and that those who gave evidence ast today’s conference could well end up giving evidence in court.

Support The Echo

Keeping the community together and the community voice loud and clear is what The Echo is about. More than ever we need your help to keep this voice alive and thriving in the community.

Like all businesses we are struggling to keep food on the table of all our local and hard working journalists, artists, sales, delivery and drudges who keep the news coming out to you both in the newspaper and online. If you can spare a few dollars a week – or maybe more – we would appreciate all the support you are able to give to keep the voice of independent, local journalism alive.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Appeal to locate man last seen at Casino on way to Tweed

Police are appealing for public assistance to locate a man from Grafton missing from the North Coast area.

Do you still need help to get two rooms fixed after the 2022 flood?

More than 80 Lismore residents have had help getting a few rooms in their flood-impacted homes re-sheeted and habitable following the devastating 2022 floods.  The...

$15,000 fine and warnings over illegal logging in Kyogle Shire

Urbenville-based logging company Rojech Pty Ltd were fined $15,000 earlier this month over logging operations near the entrance to the Border Ranges National Park in Kyogle Shire.

No street gathering policy for Ballina Shire

A majority of Ballina Shire councillors have voted against a Greens-led motion for a new policy enabling resident-led street closures for gatherings and play.